Sunday, August 21, 2016

Folding Beijing - Uncanny Magazine


Folding Beijing

by Hao Jingfang, translated by Ken Liu

At ten of five in the morning, Lao Dao crossed the busy pedestrian lane on his way to find Peng Li.

After the end of his shift at the waste processing station, Lao Dao had gone home, first to shower and then to change. He was wearing a white shirt and a pair of brown pants—the only decent clothes he owned. The shirt's cuffs were frayed, so he rolled them up to his elbows. Lao Dao was forty–eight, single, and long past the age when he still took care of his appearance. As he had no one to pester him about the domestic details, he had simply kept this outfit for years. Every time he wore it, he'd come home afterward, take off the shirt and pants, and fold them up neatly to put away. Working at the waste processing station meant there were few occasions that called for the outfit, save a wedding now and then for a friend's son or daughter.

Today, however, he was apprehensive about meeting strangers without looking at least somewhat respectable. After five hours at the waste processing station, he also had misgivings about how he smelled.

People who had just gotten off work filled the road. Men and women crowded every street vendor, picking through local produce and bargaining loudly. Customers packed the plastic tables at the food hawker stalls, which were immersed in the aroma of frying oil. They ate heartily with their faces buried in bowls of hot and sour rice noodles, their heads hidden by clouds of white steam. Other stands featured mountains of jujubes and walnuts, and hunks of cured meat swung overhead. This was the busiest hour of the day—work was over, and everyone was hungry and loud.

Lao Dao squeezed through the crowd slowly. A waiter carrying dishes shouted and pushed his way through the throng. Lao Dao followed close behind.

Peng Li lived some ways down the lane. Lao Dao climbed the stairs but Peng wasn't home. A neighbor said that Peng usually didn't return until right before market closing time, but she didn't know exactly when.

Lao Dao became anxious. He glanced down at his watch: Almost 5:00 AM.

He went back downstairs to wait at the entrance of the apartment building. A group of hungry teenagers squatted around him, devouring their food. He recognized two of them because he remembered meeting them a couple of times at Peng Li's home. Each kid had a plate of chow mein or chow fun, and they shared two dishes family–style. The dishes were a mess while pairs of chopsticks continued to search for elusive, overlooked bits of meat amongst the chopped peppers. Lao Dao sniffed his forearms again to be sure that the stench of garbage was off of him. The noisy, quotidian chaos around him assured him with its familiarity.

"Listen, do you know how much they charge for an order of twice–cooked pork over there?" a boy named Li asked.

"Fuck! I just bit into some sand," a heavyset kid named Ding said while covering his mouth with one hand, which had very dirty fingernails. "We need to get our money back from the vendor!"

Li ignored him. "Three hundred and forty yuan!" said Li. "You hear that? Three forty! For twice–cooked pork! And for boiled beef? Four hundred and twenty!"

"How could the prices be so expensive?" Ding mumbled as he clutched his cheek. "What do they put in there?"

The other two youths weren't interested in the conversation and concentrated on shoveling food from the plate into the mouth. Li watched them, and his yearning gaze seemed to go through them and focus on something beyond.

Lao Dao's stomach growled. He quickly averted his eyes, but it was too late. His empty stomach felt like an abyss that made his body tremble. It had been a month since he last had a morning meal. He used to spend about a hundred each day on this meal, which translated to three thousand for the month. If he could stick to his plan for a whole year, he'd be able to save enough to afford two months of tuition for Tangtang's kindergarten.

He looked into the distance: The trucks of the city cleaning crew were approaching slowly.

He began to steel himself. If Peng Li didn't return in time, he would have to go on this journey without consulting him. Although it would make the trip far more difficult and dangerous, time was of the essence and he had to go. The loud chants of the woman next to him hawking her jujube interrupted his thoughts and gave him a headache. The peddlers at the other end of the road began to pack up their wares, and the crowd, like fish in a pond disturbed by a stick, dispersed. No one was interested in fighting the city cleaning crew. As the vendors got out of the way, the cleaning trucks patiently advanced. Vehicles were normally not allowed in the pedestrian lane, but the cleaning trucks were an exception. Anybody who dilly–dallied would be packed up by force.

Finally, Peng Li appeared: His shirt unbuttoned, a toothpick dangling between his lips, strolling leisurely and burping from time to time. Now in his sixties, Peng had become lazy and slovenly. His cheeks drooped like the jowls of a Shar–Pei, giving him the appearance of being perpetually grumpy. Looking at him now, one might get the impression that he was a loser whose only ambition in life was a full belly. However, even as a child, Lao Dao had heard his father recounting Peng Li's exploits when he had been a young man.

Lao Dao went up to meet Peng in the street. Before Peng Li could greet him, Lao Dao blurted out, "I don't have time to explain, but I need to get to First Space. Can you tell me how?"

Peng Li was stunned. It had been ten years since anyone brought up First Space with him. He held the remnant of the toothpick in his fingers—it had broken between his teeth without his being aware of it. For some seconds, he said nothing, but then he saw the anxiety on Lao Dao's face and dragged him toward the apartment building. "Come into my place and let's talk. You have to start from there anyway to get to where you want to go."

The city cleaning crew was almost upon them, and the crowd scattered like autumn leaves in a wind. "Go home! Go home! The Change is about to start," someone called from atop one of the trucks.

Peng Li took Lao Dao upstairs into his apartment. His ordinary, single–occupancy public housing unit was sparsely furnished: Six square meters in area, a washroom, a cooking corner, a table and a chair, a cocoon–bed equipped with storage drawers underneath for clothes and miscellaneous items. The walls were covered with water stains and footprints, bare save for a few haphazardly installed hooks for jackets, pants, and linens. Once he entered, Peng took all the clothes and towels off the wall–hooks and stuffed them into one of the drawers. During the Change, nothing was supposed to be unsecured. Lao Dao had once lived in a single–occupancy unit just like this one. As soon as he entered, he felt the flavor of the past hanging in the air.

Peng Li glared at Lao Dao. "I'm not going to show you the way unless you tell me why."

It was already five thirty. Lao Dao had only half an hour left.

Lao Dao gave him the bare outlines of the story: Picking up the bottle with a message inside; hiding in the trash chute; being entrusted with the errand in Second Space; making his decision and coming here for guidance. He had so little time that he had to leave right away.

"You hid in the trash chutes last night to sneak into Second Space?" Peng Li frowned. "That means you had to wait twenty–four hours!"

"For two hundred thousand yuan?" Lao Dao said, "Even hiding for a week would be worth it."

"I didn't know you were so short on money."

Lao Dao was silent for a moment. "Tangtang is going to be old enough for kindergarten in a year. I've run out of time."

Lao Dao's research on kindergarten tuition had shocked him. For schools with decent reputations, the parents had to show up with their bedrolls and line up a couple of days before registration. The two parents had to take turns so that while one held their place in the line, the other could go to the bathroom or grab a bite to eat. Even after lining up for forty–plus hours, a place wasn't guaranteed. Those with enough money had already bought up most of the openings for their offspring, so the poorer parents had to endure the line, hoping to grab one of the few remaining spots. Mind you, this was just for decent schools. The really good schools? Forget about lining up—every opportunity was sold off to those with money. Lao Dao didn't harbor unrealistic hopes, but Tangtang had loved music since she was an eighteen–month–old. Every time she heard music in the streets, her face lit up and she twisted her little body and waved her arms about in a dance. She looked especially cute during those moments. Lao Dao was dazzled as though surrounded by stage lights. No matter how much it cost, he vowed to send Tangtang to a kindergarten that offered music and dance lessons.

Peng Li took off his shirt and washed while he spoke with Lao Dao. The "washing" consisted only of splashing some drops of water over his face because the water was already shut off and only a thin trickle came out of the faucet. Peng Li took down a dirty towel from the wall and wiped his face carelessly before stuffing the towel into a drawer as well. His moist hair gave off an oily glint.

"What are you working so hard for?" Peng Li asked. "It's not like she's your real daughter."

"I don't have time for this," Lao Dao said. "Just tell me the way."

Peng Li sighed. "Do you understand that if you're caught, it's not just a matter of paying a fine? You're going to be locked up for months."

"I thought you had gone there multiple times."

"Just four times. I got caught the fifth time."

"That's more than enough. If I could make it four times, it would be no big deal to get caught once."

Lao Dao's errand required him to deliver a message to First Space—success would earn him a hundred thousand yuan, and if he managed to bring back a reply, two hundred thousand. Sure, it was illegal, but no one would be harmed, and as long as he followed the right route and method, the probability of being caught wasn't great. And the cash, the cash was very real. He could think of no reason to not take up the offer. He knew that when Peng Li was younger, he had snuck into First Space multiple times to smuggle contraband and made quite a fortune. There was a way.

It was a quarter to six. He had to get going, now.

Peng Li sighed again. He could see it was useless to try to dissuade Lao Dao. He was old enough to feel lazy and tired of everything, but he remembered how he had felt as a younger man and he would have made the same choice as Lao Dao. Back then, he didn't care about going to prison. What was the big deal? You lost a few months and got beaten up a few times, but the money made it worthwhile. As long as you refused to divulge the source of the money no matter how much you suffered, you could survive it. The Security Bureau's citation was nothing more than routine enforcement.

Peng Li took Lao Dao to his back window and pointed at the narrow path hidden in the shadows below.

"Start by climbing down the drain pipe from my unit. Under the felt cloth you'll find hidden footholds I installed back in the day—if you stick close enough to the wall, the cameras won't see you. Once you're on the ground, stick to the shadows and head that way until you get to the edge. You'll feel as well as see the cleft. Follow the cleft and go north. Remember, go north."

Then Peng Li explained the technique for entering First Space as the ground turned during the Change. He had to wait until the ground began to cleave and rise. Then, from the elevated edge, he had to swing over and scramble about fifty meters over the cross section until he reached the other side of the turning earth, climb over, and head east. There, he would find a bush that he could hold onto as the ground descended and closed up. He could then conceal himself in the bush. Before Peng had even finished his explanation, Lao Dao was already halfway out the window, getting ready to climb down.

Peng Li held onto Lao Dao and made sure his foot was securely in the first foothold. Then he stopped. "I'm going to say something that you might not want to hear. I don't think you should go. Over there … is not so great. If you go, you'll end up feeling your own life is shit, pointless."

Lao Dao was reaching down with his other foot, testing for the next foothold. His body strained against the windowsill and his words came out labored. "It doesn't matter. I already know my life is shit without having gone there."

"Take care of yourself," Peng Li said.

Lao Dao followed Peng Li's directions and groped his way down as quickly as he dared; the footholds felt very secure. He looked up and saw Peng Li light up a cigarette next to the window, taking deep drags. Peng Li put out the cigarette, leaned out, and seemed about to say something more, but ultimately he retreated back into his unit quietly. He closed his window, which glowed with a faint light.

Lao Dao imagined Peng Li crawling into his cocoon–bed at the last minute, right before the Change. Like millions of others across the city, the cocoon–bed would release a soporific gas that put him into deep sleep. He would feel nothing as his body was transported by the flipping world, and he would not open his eyes again until tomorrow evening, forty–hours later. Peng Li was no longer young; he was no longer different from the other fifty million who lived in Third Space.

Lao Dao climbed faster, barely touching the footholds. When he was close enough to the ground, he let go and landed on all fours. Luckily, Peng Li's unit was only on the fourth story, not too far up. He got up and ran through the shadow cast by the building next to the lake. He saw the crevice in the grass where the ground would open up.

But before he reached it, he heard the muffled rumbling from behind him, interrupted by a few crisp clangs. Lao Dao turned around and saw Peng Li's building break in half. The top half folded down and pressed toward him, slowly but inexorably.

Shocked, Lao Dao stared at the sight for a few moments before recovering. He raced to the fissure in the ground, and lay prostrate next to it.

The Change began. This was a process repeated every twenty–four hours. The whole world started to turn. The sound of steel and masonry folding, grating, colliding filled the air, like an assembly line grinding to a halt. The towering buildings of the city gathered and merged into solid blocks; neon signs, shop awnings, balconies, and other protruding fixtures retracted into the buildings or flattened themselves into a thin layer against the walls, like skin. Every inch of space was utilized as the buildings compacted themselves into the smallest space.

The ground rose up. Lao Dao watched and waited until the fissure was wide enough. He crawled over the marble–lined edge onto the earthen wall, grabbing onto bits of metal protruding out of the soil. As the cleft widened and the walls elevated, he climbed, using his hands as well as feet. At first, he was climbing down, testing for purchase with his feet. But soon, as the entire section of ground rotated, he was lifted into the air, and up and down flipped around.

Lao Dao was thinking about last night.

He had cautiously stuck his head out of the trash heap, alert for any sound from the other side of the gate. The fermenting, rotting garbage around him was pungent: Greasy, fishy, even a bit sweet. He leaned against the iron gate. Outside, the world was waking up.

As soon as the yellow glow of the streetlights seeped into the seam under the lifting gate, he squatted and crawled out of the widening opening. The streets were empty; lights came on in the tall buildings, story by story; fixtures extruded from the sides of buildings, unfolding and extending, segment by segment; porches emerged from the walls; the eaves rotated and gradually dropped down into position; stairs extended and descended to the street. On both sides of the road, one black cube after another broke apart and opened, revealing the racks and shelves inside. Signboards emerged from the tops of the cubes and connected together while plastic awnings extended from both sides of the lane to meet in the middle, forming a corridor of shops. The streets were empty, as though Lao Dao were dreaming.

The neon lights came on. Tiny flashing LEDs on top of the shops formed into characters advertising jujubes from Xinjiang, lapi noodles from Northeast China, bran dough from Shanghai, and cured meats from Hunan.

For the rest of the day, Lao Dao couldn't forget the scene. He had lived in this city for forty–eight years, but he had never seen such a sight. His days had always started with the cocoon and ended with the cocoon, and the time in between was spent at work or navigating dirty tables at hawker stalls and loudly bargaining crowds surrounding street vendors. This was the first time he had seen the world, bare.

Every morning, an observer at some distance from the city—say, a truck driver waiting on the highway into Beijing—could see the entire city fold and unfold.

At six in the morning, the truck drivers usually got out of their cabs and walked to the side of the highway, where they rubbed their eyes, still drowsy after an uncomfortable night in the truck. Yawning, they greeted each other and gazed at the distant city center. The break in the highway was just outside the Seventh Ring Road, while all the ground rotation occurred within the Sixth Ring Road. The distance was perfect for taking in the whole city, like gazing at an island in the sea.

In the early dawn, the city folded and collapsed. The skyscrapers bowed submissively like the humblest servants until their heads touched their feet; then they broke again, folded again, and twisted their necks and arms, stuffing them into the gaps. The compacted blocks that used to be the skyscrapers shuffled and assembled into dense, gigantic Rubik's Cubes that fell into a deep slumber.

The ground then began to turn. Square by square, pieces of the earth flipped 180 degrees around an axis, revealing the buildings on the other side. The buildings unfolded and stood up, awakening like a herd of beasts under the gray–blue sky. The island that was the city settled in the orange sunlight, spread open, and stood still as misty gray clouds roiled around it.

The truck drivers, tired and hungry, admired the endless cycle of urban renewal.

The folding city was divided into three spaces. One side of the earth was First Space, population five million. Their allotted time lasted from six o'clock in the morning to six o'clock the next morning. Then the space went to sleep, and the earth flipped.

The other side was shared by Second Space and Third Space. Twenty–five million people lived in Second Space, and their allotted time lasted from six o'clock on that second day to ten o'clock at night. Fifty million people lived in Third Space, allotted the time from ten o'clock at night to six o'clock in the morning, at which point First Space returned. Time had been carefully divided and parceled out to separate the populations: Five million enjoyed the use of twenty–four hours, and seventy–five million enjoyed the next twenty–four hours.

The structures on two sides of the ground were not even in weight. To remedy the imbalance, the earth was made thicker in First Space, and extra ballast buried in the soil to make up for the missing people and buildings. The residents of First Space considered the extra soil a natural emblem of their possession of a richer, deeper heritage.

Lao Dao had lived in Third Space since birth. He understood very well the reality of his situation, even without Peng Li pointing it out. He was a waste worker; he had processed trash for twenty–eight years, and would do so for the foreseeable future. He had not found the meaning of his existence or the ultimate refuge of cynicism; instead, he continued to hold onto the humble place assigned to him in life.

Lao Dao had been born in Beijing. His father was also a waste worker. His father told him that when Lao Dao was born, his father had just gotten his job, and the family had celebrated for three whole days. His father had been a construction worker, one of millions of other construction workers who had come to Beijing from all over China in search of work. His father and others like him had built this folding city. District by district, they had transformed the old city. Like termites swarming over a wooden house, they had chewed up the wreckage of the past, overturned the earth, and constructed a brand new world. They had swung their hammers and wielded their adzes, keeping their heads down; brick by brick, they had walled themselves off until they could no longer see the sky. Dust had obscured their views, and they had not known the grandeur of their work. Finally, when the completed building stood up before them like a living person, they had scattered in terror, as though they had given birth to a monster. But after they calmed down, they realized what an honor it would be to live in such a city in the future, and so they had continued to toil diligently and docilely, to meekly seek out any opportunity to remain in the city. It was said that when the folding city was completed, more than eighty million construction workers had wanted to stay. Ultimately, no more than twenty million were allowed to settle.

It had not been easy to get a job at the waste processing station. Although the work only involved sorting trash, so many applied that stringent selection criteria had to be imposed: The desired candidates had to be strong, skillful, discerning, organized, diligent, and unafraid of the stench or difficult environment. Strong–willed, Lao Dao's father had held fast onto the thin reed of opportunity as the tide of humanity surged and then receded around him, until he found himself a survivor on the dry beach.

His father had then kept his head down and labored away in the acidic rotten fetor of garbage and crowding for twenty years. He had built this city; he was also a resident and a decomposer.

Construction of the folding city had been completed two years before Lao Dao's birth. He had never been anywhere else, and had never harbored the desire to go anywhere else. He finished elementary school, middle school, high school, and took the annual college entrance examination three times—failing each time. In the end, he became a waste worker, too. At the waste processing station, he worked for five hours each shift, from eleven at night to four in the morning. Together with tens of thousands of co–workers, he mechanically and quickly sorted through the trash, picking out recyclable bits from the scraps of life from First Space and Second Space and tossing them into the processing furnace. Every day, he faced the trash on the conveyer belt flowing past him like a river, and he scraped off the leftover food from plastic bowls, picked out broken glass bottles, tore off the clean, thin backing from blood–stained sanitary napkins, stuffing it into the recyclables can marked with green lines. This was their lot: to eke out a living by performing the repetitive drudgery as fast as possible, to toil hour after hour for rewards as thin as the wings of cicadas.

Twenty million waste workers lived in Third Space; they were the masters of the night. The other thirty million made a living by selling clothes, food, fuel, or insurance, but most people understood that the waste workers were the backbone of Third Space's prosperity. Each time he strolled through the neon–bedecked night streets, Lao Dao thought he was walking under rainbows made of food scraps. He couldn't talk about this feeling with others. The younger generation looked down on the profession of the waste worker. They tried to show off on the dance floors of nightclubs, hoping to find jobs as DJs or dancers. Even working at a clothing store seemed a better choice: their fingers would be touching thin fabric instead of scrabbling through rotting garbage for plastic or metal. The young were no longer so terrified about survival; they cared far more about appearances.

Lao Dao didn't despise his work. But when he had gone to Second Space, he had been terrified of being despised.

The previous morning, Lao Dao had snuck his way out of the trash chute with a slip of paper and tried to find the author of the slip based on the address written on it.

Second Space wasn't far from Third Space. They were located on the same side of the ground, though they were divided in time. At the Change, the buildings of one space folded and retracted into the ground as the buildings of another space extended into the air, segment by segment, using the tops of the buildings of the other space as its foundation. The only difference between the spaces was the density of buildings. Lao Dao had to wait a full day and night inside the trash chute for the opportunity to emerge as Second Space unfolded. Although this was the first time he had been to Second Space, he wasn't anxious. He only worried about the rotting smell on him.

Luckily, Qin Tian was a generous soul. Perhaps he had been prepared for what sort of person would show up since the moment he put that slip of paper inside the bottle.

Qin Tian was very kind. He knew at a glance why Lao Dao had come. He pulled him inside his home, offered him a hot bath, and gave him one of his own bathrobes to wear. "I have to count on you," Qin Tian said.

Qin was a graduate student living in a university–owned apartment. He had three roommates, and besides the four bedrooms, the apartment had a kitchen and two bathrooms. Lao Dao had never taken a bath in such a spacious bathroom, and he really wanted to soak for a while and get rid of the smell on his body. But he was also afraid of getting the bathtub dirty and didn't dare to rub his skin too hard with the washcloth. The jets of bubbles coming out of the bathtub walls startled him, and being dried by hot jets of air made him uncomfortable. After the bath, he picked up the bathrobe from Qin Tian and only put it on after hesitating for a while. He laundered his own clothes, as well as a few other shirts casually left in a basin. Business was business, and he didn't want to owe anyone any favors.

Qin Tian wanted to send a gift to a woman he liked. They had gotten to know each other from work when Qin Tian had been given the opportunity to go to First Space for an internship with the UN Economic Office, where she was also working. The internship had lasted only a month. Qin told Lao Dao that the young woman was born and bred in First Space, with very strict parents. Her father wouldn't allow her to date a boy from Second Space, and that was why he couldn't contact her through regular channels. Qin was optimistic about the future; he was going to apply to the UN's New Youth Project after graduation, and if he were to be chosen, he would be able to go to work in First Space. He still had another year of school left before he would get his degree, but he was going crazy pining for her. He had made a rose–shaped locket for her that glowed in the dark: This was the gift he would use to ask for her hand in marriage.

"I was attending a symposium, you know, the one that discussed the UN's debt situation? You must have heard of it… anyway, I saw her, and I was like, Ah! I went over right away to talk to her. She was helping the VIPs to their seats, and I didn't know what to say, so I just followed her around. Finally, I pretended that I had to find interpreters, and I asked her to help me. She was so gentle, and her voice was really soft. I had never really asked a girl out, you understand, so I was super nervous… Later, after we started dating, I brought up how we met… Why are you laughing? Yes, we dated. No, I don't think we quite got to that kind of relationship, but… well, we kissed." Qin Tian laughed as well, a bit embarrassed. "I'm telling the truth! Don't you believe me? Yes, I guess sometimes even I can't believe it. Do you think she really likes me?"

"I have no idea," Lao Dao said. "I've never met her."

One of Qin Tian's roommates came over, and smiling, said, "Uncle, why are you taking his question so seriously? That's not a real question. He just wants to hear you say, 'Of course she loves you! You're so handsome.'"

"She must be beautiful."

"I'm not afraid that you'll laugh at me." Qin Tian paced back and forth in front of Lao Dao. "When you see her, you'll understand the meaning of 'peerless elegance.'"

Qin Tian stopped, sinking into a reverie. He was thinking of Yi Yan's mouth. Her mouth was perhaps his favorite part of her: So tiny, so smooth, with a full bottom lip that glowed with a natural, healthy pink, making him want to give it a loving bite. Her neck also aroused him. Sometimes it appeared so thin that the tendons showed, but the lines were straight and pretty. The skin was fair and smooth, extending down into the collar of her blouse so that his gaze lingered on her second button. The first time he tried to kiss her, she had moved her lips away shyly. He had persisted until she gave in, closing her eyes and returning the kiss. Her lips had felt so soft, and his hands had caressed the curve of her waist and backside, again and again. From that day on, he had lived in the country of longing. She was his dream at night, and also the light he saw when he trembled in his own hand.

Qin Tian's roommate was called Zhang Xian, who seemed to relish the opportunity to converse with Lao Dao.

Zhang Xian asked Lao Dao about life in Third Space, and mentioned that he actually wanted to live in Third Space for a while. He had been given the advice that if he wanted to climb up the ladder of government administration, some managerial experience in Third Space would be very helpful. Several prominent officials had all started their careers as Third Space administrators before being promoted to First Space. If they had stayed in Second Space, they wouldn't have gone anywhere and would have spent the rest of their careers as low–level administrative cadres. Zhang Xian's ambition was to eventually enter government service, and he was certain he knew the right path. Still, he wanted to go work at a bank for a couple of years first and earn some quick money. Since Lao Dao seemed noncommittal about his plans, Zhang Xian thought Lao Dao disapproved of his careerism.

"The current government is too inefficient and ossified," he added quickly, "slow to respond to challenges, and I don't see much hope for systematic reform. When I get my opportunity, I'll push for rapid reforms: Anyone who's incompetent will be fired." Since Lao Dao still didn't seem to show much reaction, he added, "I'll also work to expand the pool of candidates for government service and promotion, including opening up opportunities for candidates from Third Space."

Lao Dao said nothing. It wasn't because he disapproved; rather, he found it hard to believe Zhang Xian.

While he talked with Lao Dao, Zhang Xian was also putting on a tie and fixing his hair in front of the mirror. He had on a shirt with light blue stripes, and the tie was a bright blue. He closed his eyes and frowned as the mist of hairspray settled around his face, whistling all the while.

Zhang Xian left with his briefcase for his internship at the bank. Qin Tian said he had to get going as well since he had classes that would last until four in the afternoon. Before he left, he transferred fifty thousand yuan over the net to Lao Dao's account while Lao Dao watched, and explained that he would transfer the rest after Lao Dao succeeded in his mission.

"Have you been saving up for this for a while?" Lao Dao asked. "You're a student, so money is probably tight. I can accept less if necessary."

"Don't worry about it. I'm on a paid internship with a financial advisory firm. They pay me around a hundred thousand each month, so the total I'm promising you is about two months of my salary. I can afford it."

Lao Dao said nothing. He earned the standard salary of ten thousand each month.

"Please bring back her answer," Qin Tian said.

"I'll do my best."

"Help yourself to the fridge if you get hungry. Just stay put here and wait for the Change."

Lao Dao looked outside the window. He couldn't get used to the sunlight, which was a bright white, not the yellow he was used to. The street seemed twice as wide in the sun as what Lao Dao remembered from Third Space, and he wasn't sure if that was a visual illusion. The buildings here weren't nearly as tall as buildings in Third Space. The sidewalks were filled with people walking very fast, and from time to time, some trotted and tried to shove their way through the crowd, causing those in front of them to begin running as well. Everyone seemed to run across intersections. The men dressed mostly in western suits while the women wore blouses and short skirts, with scarves around their necks and compact, rigid purses in their hands that lent them an air of competence and efficiency. The street was filled with cars, and as they waited at intersections for the light to change, the drivers stuck their heads out of the windows, gazing ahead anxiously. Lao Dao had never seen so many cars; he was used to the mass–transit maglev packed with passengers whooshing by him.

Around noon, he heard noises in the hallway outside the apartment. Lao Dao peeked out of the peephole in the door. The floor of the hallway had transformed into a moving conveyor belt, and bags of trash left at the door of each apartment were shoved onto the conveyor belt to be deposited into the chute at the end. Mist filled the hall, turning into soap bubbles that drifted through the air, and then water washed the floor, followed by hot steam.

A noise from behind Lao Dao startled him. He turned around and saw that another of Qin Tian's roommates had emerged from his bedroom. The young man ignored Lao Dao, his face impassive. He went to some machine next to the balcony and pushed some buttons, and the machine came to life, popping, whirring, grinding. Eventually, the noise stopped, and Lao Dao smelled something delicious. The young man took out a piping hot plate of food from the machine and returned to his room. Through the half–open bedroom door, Lao Dao could see that the young man was sitting on the floor in a pile of blankets and dirty socks, and staring at his wall as he ate and laughed, pushing up his glasses from time to time. After he was done eating, he left the plate at his feet, stood up, and began to fight someone invisible as he faced the wall. He struggled, his breathing labored, as he wrestled the unseen enemy.

Lao Dao's last memory of Second Space was the refined air with which everyone conducted themselves before the Change. Looking down from the window of the apartment, everything seemed so orderly that he felt a hint of envy. Starting at a quarter past nine, the stores along the street turned off their lights one after another; groups of friends, their faces red with drink, said goodbye in front of restaurants. Young couples kissed next to taxicabs. And then everyone returned to their homes, and the world went to sleep.

It was ten at night. He returned to his world to go to work.

There was no trash chute connecting First Space directly with Third Space. The trash from First Space had to pass through a set of metal gates to be transported into Third Space, and the gates shut as soon as the trash went through. Lao Dao didn't like the idea of having to go over the flipping ground, but he had no choice.

As the wind whipped around him, he crawled up the still–rotating earth toward First Space. He grabbed onto metal structural elements protruding from the soil, struggling to balance his body and calm his heart, until he finally managed to scrabble over the rim of this most distant world. He felt dizzy and nauseated from the intense climb, and forcing down his churning stomach, he remained still on the ground for a while.

By the time he got up, the sun had risen.

Lao Dao had never seen such a sight. The sun rose gradually. The sky was a deep and pure azure, with an orange fringe at the horizon, decorated with slanted, thin wisps of cloud. The eaves of a nearby building blocked the sun, and the eaves appeared especially dark while the background was dazzlingly bright. As the sun continued to rise, the blue of the sky faded a little, but seemed even more tranquil and clear. Lao Dao stood up and ran at the sun; he wanted to catch a trace of that fading golden color. Silhouettes of waving tree branches broke up the sky. His heart leapt wildly. He had never imagined that a sunrise could be so moving.

After a while, he slowed down and calmed himself. He was standing in the middle of the street, lined on both sides with tall trees and wide lawns. He looked around, and he couldn't see any buildings at all. Confused, he wondered if he had really reached First Space. He pondered the two rows of sturdy gingkoes.

He backed up a few steps and turned to look in the direction he had come from. There was a road sign next to the street. He took out his phone and looked at the map—although he wasn't authorized to download live maps from First Space, he had downloaded and stored some maps before leaving on this trip. He found where he was as well as where he needed to be. He was standing next to a large open park, and the seam he had emerged from was next to a lake in that park.

Lao Dan ran about a kilometer through the deserted streets until he reached the residential district containing his destination. He hid behind some bushes and observed the beautiful house from a distance.

At eight thirty, Yi Yan came out of the house.

She was indeed as elegant as Qin Tian's description had suggested, though perhaps not as pretty. Lao Dao wasn't surprised, however. No woman could possibly be as beautiful as Qin Tian's verbal portrait. He also understood why Qin Tian had spoken so much of her mouth. Her eyes and nose were fairly ordinary. She had a good figure: Tall, with delicate bones. She wore a milky white dress with a flowing skirt. Her belt was studded with pearls, and she had on black heels.

Lao Dao walked up to her. To avoid startling her, he approached from the front, and bowed deeply when he was still some distance away.

She stood still, looking at him in surprise.

Lao Dao came closer and explained his mission. He took out the envelope with the locket and Qin Tian's letter.

She looked alarmed. "Please leave," she whispered. "I can't talk to you right now."

"Uh… I don't really need to talk to you," Lao Dao said. "I just need to give you this letter."

She refused to take it from him, clasping her hands tightly. "I can't accept this now. Please leave. Really, I'm begging you. All right?" She took out a business card from her purse and handed it to him. "Come find me at this address at noon."

Lao Dao looked at the card. At the top was the name of a bank.

"At noon," she said. "Wait for me in the underground supermarket."

Lao Dao could tell how anxious she was. He nodded, put the card away, and returned to hide behind the bushes. Soon, a man emerged from the house and stopped next to her. The man looked to be about Lao Dao's age, or maybe a couple of years younger. Dressed in a dark gray, well–fitted suit, he was tall and broad–shouldered. Not fat, just thickset. His face was nondescript: Round, a pair of glasses, hair neatly combed to one side.

The man grabbed Yi Yan around the waist and kissed her on the lips. Yi Yan seemed to give in to the kiss reluctantly.

Understanding began to dawn on Lao Dao.

A single–rider cart arrived in front of the house. The black cart had two wheels and a canopy, and resembled an ancient carriage or rickshaw one might see on TV, except there was no horse or person pulling the cart. The cart stopped and dipped forward. Yi Yan stepped in, sat down, and arranged the skirt of the dress neatly around her knees. The cart straightened and began to move at a slow, steady pace, as though pulled by some invisible horse. After Yi Yan left, a driverless car arrived, and the man got in.

Lao Dao paced in place. He felt something was pushing at his throat, but he couldn't articulate it. Standing in the sun, he closed his eyes. The clean, fresh air filled his lungs and provided some measure of comfort.

A moment later, he was on his way. The address Yi Yan had given him was to the east, a little more than three kilometers away. There were very few people in the pedestrian lane, and only scattered cars sped by in a blur on the eight–lane avenue. Occasionally, well–dressed women passed Lao Dao in two–wheeled carts. The passengers adopted such graceful postures that it was as though they were in some fashion show. No one paid any attention to Lao Dao. The trees swayed in the breeze, and the air in their shade seemed suffused with the perfume from the elegant women.

Yi Yan's office was in the Xidan commercial district. There were no skyscrapers at all, only a few low buildings scattered around a large park. The buildings seemed isolated from each other but were really parts of a single compound connected via underground passages.

Lao Dao found the supermarket. He was early. As soon as he came in, a small shopping cart began to follow him around. Every time he stopped by a shelf, the screen on the cart displayed the names of the goods on the shelf, their description, customer reviews, and comparison with other brands in the same category. All merchandise in the supermarket seemed to be labeled in foreign languages. The packaging for all the food products was very refined, and small cakes and fruits were enticingly arranged on plates for customers. He didn't dare to touch anything, keeping his distance as though they were dangerous, exotic animals. There seemed to be no guards or clerks in the whole market.

More customers appeared before noon. Some men in suits came into the market, grabbed sandwiches, and waved them at the scanner next to the door before hurrying out. No one paid any attention to Lao Dao as he waited in an obscure corner near the door.

Yi Yan appeared, and Lao Dao went up to her. Yi Yan glanced around, and without saying anything, led Lao Dao to a small restaurant next door. Two small robots dressed in plaid skirts greeted them, took Yi Yan's purse, brought them to a booth, and handed them menus. Yi Yan pressed a few spots on the menu to make her selection and handed the menu back to the robot. The robot turned and glided smoothly on its wheels to the back.

Yi Yan and Lao Dao sat mutely across from each other. Lao Dao took out the envelope.

Yi Yan still didn't take it from him. "Can you let me explain?"

Lao Dao pushed the envelope across the table. "Please take this first."

Yi Yan pushed it back.

"Can you let me explain first?"

"You don't need to explain anything," Lao Dao said. "I didn't write this letter. I'm just the messenger."

"But you have to go back and give him an answer." Yi Yan looked down. The little robot returned with two plates, one for each of them. On each plate were two slices of some kind of red sashimi, arranged like flower petals. Yi Yan didn't pick up her chopsticks, and neither did Lao Dao. The envelope rested between the two plates, and neither touched it. "I didn't betray him. When I met him last year, I was already engaged. I didn't lie to him or conceal the truth from him on purpose… Well, maybe I did lie, but it was because he assumed and guessed. He saw Wu Wen come to pick me up once, and he asked me if he was my father. I… I couldn't answer him, you know? It was just too embarrassing. I…"

Yi Yan couldn't speak any more.

Lao Dao waited a while. "I'm not interested in what happened between you two. All I care about is that you take the letter."

Yi Yan kept her head down, and then she looked up. "After you go back, can you… help me by not telling him everything?"

"Why?"

"I don't want him to think that I was just playing with his feelings. I do like him, really. I feel very conflicted."

"None of this is my concern."

"Please, I'm begging you… I really do like him."

Lao Dao was silent for a while.

"But you got married in the end?"

"Wu Wen was very good to me. We'd been together several years. He knew my parents, and we'd been engaged for a long time. Also, I'm three years older than Qin Tian, and I was afraid he wouldn't like that. Qin Tian thought I was an intern, like him, and I admit that was my fault for not telling him the truth. I don't know why I said I was an intern at first, and then it became harder and harder to correct him. I never thought he would be serious."

Slowly, Yi Yan told Lao Dao her story. She was actually an assistant to the bank's president and had already been working there for two years at the time she met Qin Tian. She had been sent to the UN for training, and was helping out at the symposium. In fact, her husband earned so much money that she didn't really need to work, but she didn't like the idea of being at home all day. She worked only half days and took a half–time salary. The rest of the day was hers to do with as she pleased, and she liked learning new things and meeting new people. She really had enjoyed the months she spent training at the UN. She told Lao Dao that there were many wives like her who worked half–time. As a matter of fact, after she got off work at noon, another wealthy wife worked as the president's assistant in the afternoon. She told Lao Dao that though she had not told Qin Tian the truth, her heart was honest.

"And so"—she spooned a serving of the new hot dish onto Lao Dao's plate—"can you please not tell him, just temporarily? Please… give me a chance to explain to him myself."

Lao Dao didn't pick up his chopsticks. He was very hungry, but he felt that he could not eat this food.

"Then I'd be lying, too," Lao Dao said.

Yi Yan opened her purse, took out her wallet, and retrieved five 10,000–yuan bills. She pushed them across the table toward Lao Dao. "Please accept this token of my appreciation."

Lao Dao was stunned. He had never seen bills with such large denominations or needed to use them. Almost subconsciously, he stood up, angry. The way Yi Yan had taken out the money seemed to suggest that she had been anticipating an attempt from him to blackmail her, and he could not accept that. This is what they think of Third Spacers. He felt that if he took her money, he would be selling Qin Tian out. It was true that he really wasn't Qin Tian's friend, but he still thought of it as a kind of betrayal. Lao Dao wanted to grab the bills, throw them on the ground, and walk away. But he couldn't. He looked at the money again: The five thin notes were spread on the table like a broken fan. He could sense the power they had on him. They were baby blue in color, distinct from the brown 1,000–yuan note and the red 100–yuan note. These bills looked deeper, most distant somehow, like a kind of seduction. Several times, he wanted to stop looking at them and leave, but he couldn't.

She continued to rummage through her purse, taking everything out, until she finally found another fifty thousand yuan from an inner pocket and placed them together with the other bills. "This is all I have. Please take it and help me." She paused. "Look, the reason I don't want him to know is because I'm not sure what I'm going to do. It's possible that someday I'll have the courage to be with him."

Lao Dao looked at the ten notes spread out on the table, and then looked up at her. He sensed that she didn't believe what she was saying. Her voice was hesitant, belying her words. She was just delaying everything to the future so that she wouldn't be embarrassed now. She was unlikely to ever elope with Qin Tian, but she also didn't want him to despise her. Thus, she wanted to keep alive the possibility so that she could feel better about herself.

Lao Dao could see that she was lying to herself, but he wanted to lie to himself, too. He told himself, I have no duty to Qin Tian. All he asked was for me to deliver his message to her, and I've done that. The money on the table now represents a new commission, a commitment to keep a secret. He waited, and then told himself, Perhaps someday she really will get together with Qin Tian, and in that case I'll have done a good deed by keeping silent. Besides, I need to think about Tangtang. Why should I get myself all worked up about strangers instead of thinking about Tangtang's welfare? He felt calmer. He realized that his fingers were already touching the money.

"This is… too much." He wanted to make himself feel better. "I can't accept so much."

"It's no big deal." She stuffed the bills into his hand. "I earn this much in a week. Don't worry."

"What… what do you want me to tell him?"

"Tell him that I can't be with him now, but I truly like him. I'll write you a note to bring him." Yi Yan found a notepad in her purse; it had a picture of a peacock on the cover and the edges of the pages were golden. She ripped out a page and began to write. Her handwriting looked like a string of slanted gourds.

As Lao Dao left the restaurant, he glanced back. Yi Yan was sitting in the booth, gazing up at a painting on the wall. She looked so elegant and refined, as though she was never going to leave.

He squeezed the bills in his pocket. He despised himself, but he wanted to hold on to the money.

Lao Dao left Xidan and returned the way he had come. He felt exhausted. The pedestrian lane was lined with a row of weeping willows on one side and a row of Chinese parasol trees on the other side. It was late spring, and everything was a lush green. The afternoon sun warmed his stiff face, and brightened his empty heart.

He was back at the park from this morning. There were many people in the park now, and the two rows of gingkoes looked stately and luscious. Black cars entered the park from time to time, and most of the people in the park wore either well–fitted western suits made of quality fabric or dark–colored stylish Chinese suits, but everyone gave off a haughty air. There were also some foreigners. Some of the people conversed in small groups; others greeted each other at a distance, and then laughed as they got close enough to shake hands and walk together.

Lao Dao hesitated, trying to decide where to go. There weren't that many people in the street, and he would draw attention if he just stood here. But he would look out of place in any public area. He wanted to go back into the park, get close to the fissure, and hide in some corner to take a nap. He felt very sleepy, but he dared not sleep on the street.

He noticed that the cars entering the park didn't seem to need to stop, and so he tried to walk into the park as well. Only when he was close to the park gate did he notice that two robots were patrolling the area. While cars and other pedestrians passed their sentry line with no problems, the robots beeped as soon as Lao Dao approached and turned on their wheels to head for him. In the tranquil afternoon, the noise they made seemed especially loud. The eyes of everyone nearby turned to him. He panicked, uncertain if it was his shabby clothes that alerted the robots. He tried to whisper to the robots, claiming that his suit was left inside the park, but the robots ignored him while they continued to beep and to flash the red lights over their heads. People strolling inside the park stopped and looked at him as though looking at a thief or eccentric person. Soon, three men emerged from a nearby building and ran over. Lao Dao's heart was in his throat. He wanted to run, but it was too late.

"What's going on?" the man in the lead asked loudly.

Lao Dao couldn't think of anything to say, and he rubbed his pants compulsively.

The man in the front was in his thirties. He came up to Lao Dao and scanned him with a silver disk about the size of a button, moving his hand around Lao Dao's person. He looked at Lao Dao suspiciously, as though trying to pry open his shell with a can opener.

"There's no record of this man." The man gestured at the older man behind him. "Bring him in."

Lao Dao started to run away from the park.

The two robots silently dashed ahead of him and grabbed onto his legs. Their arms were cuffs and locked easily about his ankles. He tripped and almost fell, but the robots held him up. His arms swung through the air helplessly.

"Why are you trying to run?" The younger man stepped up and glared at him. His tone was now severe.

"I…" Lao Dao's head felt like a droning beehive. He couldn't think.

The two robots lifted Lao Dao by the legs and deposited his feet onto platforms next to their wheels. Then they drove toward the nearest building in parallel, carrying Lao Dao. Their movements were so steady, so smooth, so synchronized, that from a distance, it appeared as if Lao Dao was skating along on a pair of rollerblades, like Nezha riding on his Wind Fire Wheels.

Lao Dao felt utterly helpless. He was angry with himself for being so careless. How could he think such a crowded place would be without security measures? He berated himself for being so drowsy that he could commit such a stupid mistake. It's all over now, he thought. Not only am I not going to get my money, I'm also going to jail.

The robots followed a narrow path and reached the backdoor of the building, where they stopped. The three men followed behind. The younger man seemed to be arguing with the older man over what to do with Lao Dao, but they spoke so softly that Lao Dao couldn't hear the details. After a while, the older man came up and unlocked the robots from Lao Dao's legs. Then he grabbed him by the arm and took him upstairs.

Lao Dao sighed. He resigned himself to his fate.

The man brought him into a room. It looked like a hotel room, very spacious, bigger even than the living room in Qin Tian's apartment, and about twice the size of his own rental unit. The room was decorated in a dark shade of golden brown, with a king–sized bed in the middle. The wall at the head of the bed showed abstract patterns of shifting colors. Translucent, white curtains covered the French window, and in front of the window sat a small circular table and two comfortable chairs. Lao Dao was anxious, unsure of who the older man was and what he wanted.

"Sit, sit!" The older man clapped him on the shoulder and smiled. "Everything's fine."

Lao Dao looked at him suspiciously.

"You're from Third Space, aren't you?" The older man pulled him over to the chairs, and gestured for him to sit.

"How do you know that?" Lao Dao couldn't lie.

"From your pants." The older man pointed at the waist of his pants. "You never even cut off the label. This brand is only sold in Third Space; I remember my mother buying them for my father when I was little."

"Sir, you're…?"

"You don't need to 'Sir' me. I don't think I'm much older than you are. How old are you? I'm fifty–two."

"Forty–eight."

"See, just older by four years." He paused, and then added, "My name is Ge Daping. Why don't you just call me Lao Ge?"

Lao Dao relaxed a little. Lao Ge took off his jacket and moved his arms about to stretch out the stiff muscles. Then he filled a glass with hot water from a spigot in the wall and handed it to Lao Dao. He had a long face, and the corners of his eyes, the ends of his eyebrows, and his cheeks drooped. Even his glasses seemed about to fall off the end of his nose. His hair was naturally a bit curly and piled loosely on top of his head. As he spoke, his eyebrows bounced up and down comically. He made some tea for himself and asked Lao Dao if he wanted any. Lao Dao shook his head.

"I was originally from Third Space as well," said Lao Ge. "We're practically from the same hometown! So, you don't need to be so careful with me. I still have a bit of authority, and I won't give you up."

Lao Dao let out a long sigh, congratulating himself silently for his good luck. He recounted for Lao Ge his experiencing of going to Second Space and then coming to First Space, but omitted the details of what Yi Yan had said. He simply told Lao Ge that he had successfully delivered the message and was just waiting for the Change to head home.

Lao Ge also shared his own story with Lao Dao. He had grown up in Third Space, and his parents had worked as deliverymen. When he was fifteen, he entered a military school, and then joined the army. He worked as a radar technician in the army, and because he worked hard, demonstrated good technical skills, and had some good opportunities, he was eventually promoted to an administrative position in the radar department with the rank of brigadier general. Since he didn't come from a prominent family, that rank was about as high as he could go in the army. He then retired from the army and joined an agency in First Space responsible for logistical support for government enterprises, organizing meetings, arranging travel, and coordinating various social events. The job was blue collar in nature, but since his work involved government officials and he had to coordinate and manage, he was allowed to live in First Space. There were a considerable number of people in First Space like him—chefs, doctors, secretaries, housekeepers—skilled blue–collar workers needed to support the lifestyle of First Space. His agency had run many important social events and functions, and Lao Ge was its director.

Lao Ge might have been self–deprecating in describing himself as a "blue collar," but Lao Dao understood that anyone who could work and live in First Space had extraordinary skills. Even a chef here was likely a master of his art. Lao Ge must be very talented to have risen here from Third Space after a technical career in the army.

"You might as well take a nap," Lao Ge said. "I'll take you to get something to eat this evening."

Lao Dao still couldn't believe his good luck, and he felt a bit uneasy. However, he couldn't resist the call of the white sheets and stuffed pillows, and he fell asleep almost right away.

When he woke up, it was dark outside. Lao Ge was combing his hair in front of the mirror. He showed Lao Dao a suit lying on the sofa and told him to change. Then he pinned a tiny badge with a faint red glow to Lao Dao's lapel—a new identity.

The large open lobby downstairs was crowded. Some kind of presentation seemed to have just finished, and attendees conversed in small groups. At one end of the lobby were the open doors leading to the banquet hall; the thick doors were lined with burgundy leather. The lobby was filled with small standing tables. Each table was covered by a white tablecloth tied around the bottom with a golden bow, and the vase in the middle of each table held a lily. Crackers and dried fruits were set out next to the vases for snacking, and a long table to the side offered wine and coffee. Guests mingled and conversed among the tables while small robots holding serving trays shuttled between their legs, collecting empty glasses.

Forcing himself to be calm, Lao Dao followed Lao Ge and walked through the convivial scene into the banquet hall. He saw a large hanging banner: The Folding City at Fifty.

"What is this?" Lao Dao asked.

"A celebration!" Lao Ge was walking about and examining the set up. "Xiao Zhao, come here a minute. I want you to check the table signs one more time. I don't trust robots for things like this. Sometimes they don't know how to be flexible."

Lao Dao saw that the banquet hall was filled with large round tables with fresh flower centerpieces.

The scene seemed unreal to him. He stood in a corner and gazed up at the giant chandelier as though some dazzling reality was hanging over him, and he was but an insignificant presence at its periphery. There was a lectern set up on the dais at the front, and, behind it, the background was an ever–shifting series of images of Beijing. The photographs were perhaps taken from an airplane and captured the entirety of the city: The soft light of dawn and dusk; the dark purple and deep blue sky; clouds racing across the sky; the moon rising from a corner; the sun setting behind a roof. The aerial shots revealed the magnificence of Beijing's ancient symmetry; the modern expanse of brick courtyards and large green parks that had extended to the Sixth Ring Road; Chinese style theatres; Japanese style museums; minimalist concert halls. And then there were shots of the city as a whole, shots that included both faces of the city during the Change: The earth flipping, revealing the other side studded with skyscrapers with sharp, straight contours; men and women energetically rushing to work; neon signs lighting up the night, blotting out the stars; towering apartment buildings, cinemas, nightclubs full of beautiful people.

But there were no shots of where Lao Dao worked.

He stared at the screen intently, uncertain if they might show pictures during the construction of the folding city. He hoped to get a glimpse of his father's era. When he was little, his father had often pointed to buildings outside the window and told him stories that started with "Back then, we…" An old photograph had hung on the wall of their cramped home, and in the picture his father was laying bricks, a task his father had performed thousands, or perhaps hundreds of thousands of times. He had seen that picture so many times that he thought he was sick of it, and yet, at this moment, he hoped to see a scene of workers laying bricks, even if for just a few seconds.

He was lost in his thoughts. This was also the first time he had seen what the Change looked like from a distance. He didn't remember sitting down, and he didn't know when others had sat down next to him. A man began to speak at the lectern, but Lao Dao wasn't even listening for the first few minutes.

"… advantageous for the development of the service sector. The service economy is dependent on population size and density. Currently, the service industry of our city is responsible for more than 85 percent of our GDP, in line with the general characteristics of world–class metropolises. The other important sectors are the green economy and the recycling economy." Lao Dao was paying full attention now. "Green economy" and "recycling economy" were often mentioned at the waste processing station, and the phrases were painted on the walls in characters taller than a man. He looked closer at the speaker on the dais: An old man with silvery hair, though he appeared hale and energetic. "… all trash is now sorted and processed, and we've achieved our goals for energy conservation and pollution reduction ahead of schedule. We've developed a systematic, large–scale recycling economy in which all the rare–earth and precious metals extracted from e–waste are reused in manufacturing, and even the plastics recycling rate exceeds eighty percent. The recycling stations are directly connected to the reprocessing plants…"

Lao Dao knew of a distant relative who worked at a reprocessing plant in the technopark far from the city. The technopark was just acres and acres of industrial buildings, and he heard that all the plants over there were very similar: The machines pretty much ran on their own, and there were very few workers. At night, when the workers got together, they felt like the last survivors of some dwindling tribe in a desolate wilderness.

He drifted off again. Only the wild applause at the end of the speech pulled him out of his chaotic thoughts and back to reality. He also applauded, though he didn't know what for. He watched the speaker descend the dais and return to his place of honor at the head table. Everyone's eyes were on him.

Lao Dao saw Wu Wen, Yi Yan's husband.

Wu Wen was at the table next to the head table. As the old man who had given the speech sat down, Wu Wen walked over to offer a toast, and then he seemed to say something that got the old man's attention. The old man got up and walked with Wu Wen out of the banquet hall. Almost subconsciously, a curious Lao Dao also got up and followed them. He didn't know where Lao Ge had gone. Robots emerged to serve the dishes for the banquet.

Lao Dao emerged from the banquet hall and was back in the reception lobby. He eavesdropped on the other two from a distance and only caught snippets of conversation.

"… there are many advantages to this proposal," said Wu Wen. "Yes, I've seen their equipment… automatic waste processing… they use a chemical solvent to dissolve and digest everything and then extract reusable materials in bulk… clean, and very economical… would you please give it some consideration?"

Wu Wen kept his voice low, but Lao Dao clearly heard "waste processing." He moved closer.

The old man with the silvery hair had a complex expression. Even after Wu Wen was finished, he waited a while before speaking, "You're certain that the solvent is safe? No toxic pollution?"

Wu Wen hesitated. "The current version still generates a bit of pollution but I'm sure they can reduce it to the minimum very quickly."

Lao Dao got even closer.

The old man shook his head, staring at Wu Wen. "Things aren't that simple. If I approve your project and it's implemented, there will be major consequences. Your process won't need workers, so what are you going to do with the tens of millions of people who will lose their jobs?"

The old man turned away and returned to the banquet hall. Wu Wen remained in place, stunned. A man who had been by the old man's side—a secretary perhaps—came up to Wu Wen and said sympathetically, "You might as well go back and enjoy the meal. I'm sure you understand how this works. Employment is the number one concern. Do you really think no one has suggested similar technology in the past?"

Lao Dao understood vaguely that what they were talking about had to do with him, but he wasn't sure whether it was good news or bad. Wu Wen's expression shifted through confusion, annoyance, and then resignation. Lao Dao suddenly felt some sympathy for him: He had his moments of weakness, as well.

The secretary suddenly noticed Lao Dao.

"Are you new here?" he asked.

Lao Dao was startled. "Ah? Um…"

"What's your name? How come I wasn't informed about a new member of the staff?"

Lao Dao's heart beat wildly. He didn't know what to say. He pointed to the badge on his lapel, as though hoping the badge would speak or otherwise help him out. But the badge displayed nothing. His palms sweated. The secretary stared at him, his look growing more suspicious by the second. He grabbed another worker in the lobby, and the worker said he didn't know who Lao Dao was.

The secretary's face was now severe and dark. He grabbed Lao Dao with one hand and punched the keys on his communicator with the other hand.

Lao Dao's heart threatened to jump out of his throat, but just then, he saw Lao Ge.

Lao Ge rushed over and with a smooth gesture, hung up the secretary's communicator. Smiling, he greeted the secretary and bowed deeply. He explained that he was shorthanded for the occasion and had to ask for a colleague from another department to help out tonight. The secretary seemed to believe Lao Ge and returned to the banquet hall. Lao Ge brought Lao Dao back to his own room to avoid any further risks. If anyone really bothered to look into Lao Dao's identity, they'd discover the truth, and even Lao Ge wouldn't be able to protect him.

"I guess you're not fated to enjoy the banquet." Lao Ge laughed. "Just wait here. I'll get you some food later."

Lao Dao lay down on the bed and fell asleep again. He replayed the conversation between Wu Wen and the old man in his head. Automatic waste processing. What would that look like? Would that be a good thing or bad?

The next time he woke up, he smelled something delicious. Lao Ge had set out a few dishes on the small circular table, and was taking the last plate out of the warming oven on the wall. Lao Ge also brought over a half bottle of baijiu and filled two glasses.

"There was a table where they had only two people, and they left early so most of the dishes weren't even touched. I brought some back. It's not much, but maybe you'll enjoy the taste. Hopefully you won't hold it against me that I'm offering you leftovers."

"Not at all," Lao Dao said. "I'm grateful that I get to eat at all. These look wonderful! They must be very expensive, right?"

"The food at the banquet is prepared by the kitchen here and not for sale, so I don't know how much they'd cost in a restaurant." Lao Ge already started to eat. "They're nothing special. If I had to guess, maybe ten thousand, twenty thousand? A couple might cost thirty, forty thousand. Not more than that."

After a couple of bites, Lao Dao realized how hungry he was. He was used to skipping meals, and sometimes he could last a whole day without eating. His body would shake uncontrollably then, but he had learned to endure it. But now, the hunger was overwhelming. He wanted to chew quicker because his teeth couldn't seem to catch up to the demands of his empty stomach. He tried to wash the food down with baijiu, which was very fragrant and didn't sting his throat at all.

Lao Ge ate leisurely, and smiled as he watched Lao Dao eat.

"Oh." Now that the pangs of hunger had finally been dulled a bit, Lao Dao remembered the earlier conversation. "Who was the man giving the speech? He seemed a bit familiar."

"He's always on TV," Lao Ge said. "That's my boss. He's a man with real power—in charge of everything having to do with city operations."

"They were talking about automatic waste processing earlier. Do you think they'll really do it?"

"Hard to say." Lao Ge sipped the baijiu and let out a burp. "I suspect not. You have to understand why they went with manual processing in the first place. Back then, the situation here was similar to Europe at the end of the twentieth century. The economy was growing, but so was unemployment. Printing money didn't solve the problem. The economy refused to obey the Phillips curve."

He saw that Lao Dao looked completely lost, and laughed. "Never mind. You wouldn't understand these things anyway."

He clinked glasses with Lao Dao and the two drained their baijiu and refilled the glasses.

"I'll just stick to unemployment. I'm sure you understand the concept," Lao Ge continued. "As the cost of labor goes up and the cost of machinery goes down, at some point, it'll be cheaper to use machines than people. With the increase in productivity, the GDP goes up, but so does unemployment. What do you do? Enact policies to protect the workers? Better welfare? The more you try to protect workers, the more you increase the cost of labor and make it less attractive for employers to hire people. If you go outside the city now to the industrial districts, there's almost no one working in those factories. It's the same thing with farming. Large commercial farms contain thousands and thousands of acres of land, and everything is automated so there's no need for people. This kind of automation is absolutely necessary if you want to grow your economy—that was how we caught up to Europe and America, remember? Scaling! The problem is: Now you've gotten the people off the land and out of the factories, what are you going to do with them? In Europe, they went with the path of forcefully reducing everyone's working hours and thus increasing employment opportunities. But this saps the vitality of the economy, you understand?

"The best way is to reduce the time a certain portion of the population spends living, and then find ways to keep them busy. Do you get it? Right, shove them into the night. There's another advantage to this approach: The effects of inflation almost can't be felt at the bottom of the social pyramid. Those who can get loans and afford the interest spend all the money you print. The GDP goes up, but the cost of basic necessities does not. And most of the people won't even be aware of it."

Lao Dao listened, only half grasping what was being said. But he could detect something cold and cruel in Lao Ge's speech. Lao Ge's manner was still jovial, but he could tell Lao Ge's joking tone was just an attempt to dull the edge of his words and not hurt him. Not too much.

"Yes, it sounds a bit cold," Lao Ge admitted. "But it's the truth. I'm not trying to defend this place just because I live here. But after so many years, you grow a bit numb. There are many things in life we can't change, and all we can do is to accept and endure."

Lao Dao was finally beginning to understand Lao Ge, but he didn't know what to say.

Both became a bit drunk. They began to reminisce about the past: The foods they ate as children, schoolyard fights. Lao Ge had loved hot and sour rice noodles and stinky tofu. These were not available in First Space, and he missed them dearly. Lao Ge talked about his parents, who still lived in Third Space. He couldn't visit them often because each trip required him to apply and obtain special approval, which was very burdensome. He mentioned that there were some officially sanctioned ways to go between Third Space and First Space, and a few select people did make the trip often. He hoped that Lao Dao could bring a few things back to his parents because he felt regret and sorrow over his inability to be by their side and care for them.

Lao Dao talked about his lonely childhood. In the dim lamplight, he recalled his childhood spent alone wandering at the edge of the landfill.

It was now late night. Lao Ge had to go check up on the event downstairs, and he took Lao Dao with him. The dance party downstairs was about to be over, and tired–looking men and women emerged in twos and threes. Lao Ge said that entrepreneurs seemed to have the most energy, and often danced until the morning. The deserted banquet hall after the party looked messy and grubby, like a woman who took off her makeup after a long, tiring day. Lao Ge watched the robots trying to clean up the mess and laughed. "This is the only moment when First Space shows its true face."

Lao Dao checked the time: Three hours until the Change. He sorted his thoughts: It's time to leave.

The silver–haired speaker returned to his office after the banquet to deal with some paperwork, and then got on a video call with Europe. At midnight, he felt tired. He took off his glasses and rubbed the bridge of his nose. It was finally time to go home. He worked till midnight on most days.

The phone rang. He picked up. It was his secretary.

The research group for the conference had reported something troubling. Someone had discovered an error with one of the figures used in the pre–printed conference declaration, and the research group wanted to know if they should re–print the declaration. The old man immediately approved the request. This was very important, and they had to get it right. He asked who was responsible for this, and the secretary told him that it was Director Wu Wen.

The old man sat down on his sofa and took a nap. Around four in the morning, the phone rang again. The printing was going a bit slower than expected, and they estimated it would take another hour.

He got up and looked outside the window. All was silent. He could see Orion's bright stars twinkling against the dark sky.

The stars of Orion were reflected in the mirror–like surface of the lake. Lao Dao was sitting on the shore of the lake, waiting for the Change.

He gazed at the park at night, realizing that this was perhaps the last time he would see a sight such as this. He wasn't sad or nostalgic. This was a beautiful, peaceful place, but it had nothing to do with him. He wasn't envious or resentful. He just wanted to remember this experience. There were few lights at night here, nothing like the flashing neon that turned the streets of Third Space bright as day. The buildings of the city seemed to be asleep, breathing evenly and calmly.

At five in the morning, the secretary called again to say that the declaration had been re–printed and bound, but the documents were still in the print shop, and they wanted to know if they should delay the scheduled Change.

The old man made the decision right away. Of course they had to delay it.

At forty minutes past the hour, the printed declarations were brought to the conference site, but they still had to be stuffed into about three thousand individual folders.

Lao Dao saw the faint light of dawn. At this time during the year, the sun wouldn't have risen by six, but it was possible to see the sky brightening near the horizon.

He was prepared. He looked at his phone: only a couple more minutes until six. But strangely, there were no signs of the Change. Maybe in First Space, even the Change happens more smoothly and steadily.

At ten after six, the last copy of the declaration was stuffed into its folder.

The old man let out a held breath. He gave the order to initiate the Change.

Lao Dao noticed that the earth was finally moving. He stood up and shook the numbness out of his limbs. Carefully, he stepped up to the edge of the widening fissure. As the earth on both sides of the crack lifted up, he clambered over the edge, tested for purchase with his feet, and climbed down. The ground began to turn.

At twenty after six, the secretary called again with an emergency. Director Wu Wen had carelessly left a data key with important documents behind at the banquet hall. He was worried that the cleaning robots might remove it, and he had to go retrieve it right away.

The old man was annoyed, but he gave the order to stop the Change and reverse course.

Lao Dao was climbing slowly over the cross section of the earth when everything stopped with a jolt. After a moment, the earth started moving again, but now in reverse. The fissure was closing up. Terrified, he climbed up as fast as he dared. Scrabbling over the soil with hands and feet, he had to be careful with his movements.

The seam closed faster than he had expected. Just as he reached the top, the two sides of the crack came together. One of his lower legs was caught. Although the soil gave enough to not crush his leg or break his bones, it held him fast and he couldn't extricate himself despite several attempts. Sweat beaded on his forehead from terror and pain. Has he been discovered?

Lao Dao lay prostrate on the ground, listening. He seemed to hear steps hurrying toward him. He imagined that soon the police would arrive and catch him. They might cut off his leg and toss him in jail with the stump. He couldn't tell when his identity had been revealed. As he lay on the grass, he felt the chill of morning dew. The damp air seeped through collar and cuffs, keeping him alert and making him shiver. He silently counted the seconds, hoping against hope that this was but a technical malfunction. He tried to plan for what to say if he was caught. Maybe he should mention how honestly and diligently he had toiled for twenty–eight years and try to buy a bit of sympathy. He didn't know if he would be prosecuted in court. Fate loomed before his eyes.

Fate now pressed into his chest. Of everything he had experienced during the last forty–eight hours, the episode that had made the deepest impression was the conversation with Lao Ge at dinner. He felt that he had approached some aspect of truth, and perhaps that was why he could catch a glimpse of the outline of fate. But the outline was too distant, too cold, too out of reach. He didn't know what was the point of knowing the truth. If he could see some things clearly but was still powerless to change them, what good did that do? In his case, he couldn't even see clearly. Fate was like a cloud that momentarily took on some recognizable shape, and by the time he tried to get a closer look, the shape was gone. He knew that he was nothing more than a figure. He was but an ordinary person, one out of 51,280,000 others just like him. And if they didn't need that much precision and spoke of only 50 million, he was but a rounding error, the same as if he had never existed. He wasn't even as significant as dust. He grabbed onto the grass.

At six thirty, Wu Wen retrieved his data key. At six forty, Wu Wen was back in his home.

At six forty–five, the white–haired old man finally lay down on the small bed in his office, exhausted. The order had been issued, and the wheels of the world began to turn slowly. Transparent covers extended over the coffee table and the desk, securing everything in place. The bed released a cloud of soporific gas and extended rails on all sides; then it rose into the air. As the ground and everything on the ground turned, the bed would remain level, like a floating cradle.

The Change had started again.

After thirty minutes spent in despair, Lao Dao saw a trace of hope again. The ground was moving. He pulled his leg out as soon as the fissure opened, and then returned to the arduous climb over the cross–section as soon as the opening was wide enough. He moved with even more care than before. As circulation returned to his numb leg, his calf itched and ached as though he was being bitten by thousands of ants. Several times, he almost fell. The pain was intolerable, and he had to bite his fist to stop from screaming. He fell; he got up; he fell again; he got up again. He struggled with all his strength and skill to maintain his footing over the rotating earth.

He couldn't even remember how he had climbed up the stairs. He only remembered fainting as soon as Qin Tian opened the door to his apartment.

Lao Dao slept for ten hours in Second Space. Qin Tian found a classmate in medical school to help dress his wound. He suffered massive damage to his muscles and soft tissue, but luckily, no bones were broken. However, he was going to have some difficulty walking for a while.

After waking up, Lao Dao handed Yi Yan's letter to Qin Tian. He watched as Qin Tian read the letter, his face filling up with happiness as well as loss. He said nothing. He knew that Qin Tian would be immersed in this remote hope for a long time.

Returning to Third Space, Lao Dao felt as though he had been traveling for a month. The city was waking up slowly. Most of the residents had slept soundly, and now they picked up their lives from where they had left off the previous cycle. No one would notice that Lao Dao had been away.

As soon as the vendors along the pedestrian lane opened shop, he sat down at a plastic table and ordered a bowl of chow mein. For the first time in his life, Lao Dao asked for shredded pork to be added to the noodles. Just one time, he thought. A reward.

Then he went to Lao Ge's home and delivered the two boxes of medicine Lao Ge had bought for his parents. The two elders were no longer mobile, and a young woman with a dull demeanor lived with them as a caretaker.

Limping, he slowly returned to his own rental unit. The hallway was noisy and chaotic, filled with the commotion of a typical morning: brushing teeth, flushing toilets, arguing families. All around him were disheveled hair and half–dressed bodies.

He had to wait a while for the elevator. As soon as he got off at his floor he heard loud arguing noises. It was the two girls who lived next door, Lan Lan and Ah Bei, arguing with the old lady who collected rent. All the units in the building were public housing, but the residential district had an agent who collected rent, and each building, even each floor, had a subagent. The old lady was a long–term resident. She was thin, shriveled, and lived by herself—her son had left and nobody knew where he was. She always kept her door shut and didn't interact much with the other residents. Lan Lan and Ah Bei had moved in recently, and they worked at a clothing store. Ah Bei was shouting while Lan Lan was trying to hold her back. Ah Bei turned and shouted at Lan Lan; Lan Lan began to cry.

"We all have to follow the lease, don't we?" The old lady pointed at the scrolling text on the screen mounted on the wall. "Don't you dare accuse me of lying! Do you understand what a lease is? It's right here in black and white: In autumn and winter, there's a ten percent surcharge for heat."

"Ha!" Ah Bei lifted her chin at the old lady while combing her hair forcefully. "Do you think we are going to be fooled by such a basic trick? When we're at work, you turn off the heat. Then you charge us for the electricity we haven't been using so you can keep the extra for yourself. Do you think we were born yesterday? Every day, when we get home after work, the place is cold as an ice cellar. Just because we're new, you think you can take advantage of us?"

Ah Bei's voice was sharp and brittle, and it cut through the air like a knife. Lao Dao looked at Ah Bei, at her young, determined, angry face, and thought she was very beautiful. Ah Bei and Lan Lan often helped him by taking care of Tangtang when he wasn't home, and sometimes even made porridge for him. He wanted Ah Bei to stop shouting, to forget these trivial things and stop arguing. He wanted to tell her that a girl should sit elegantly and quietly, cover her knees with her skirt, and smile so that her pretty teeth showed. That was how you got others to love you. But he knew that that was not what Ah Bei and Lan Lan needed.

He took out a 10,000–yuan bill from his inner pocket and handed it to the old lady. His hand trembled from weakness. The old lady was stunned, and so were Ah Bei and Lan Lan. He didn't want to explain. He waved at them and returned to his home.

Tangtang was just waking up in her crib, and she rubbed her sleepy eyes. He gazed into Tangtang's face, and his exhausted heart softened. He remembered how he had found Tangtang at first in front of the waste processing station, and her dirty, tear–stained face. He had never regretted picking her up that day. She laughed, and smacked her lips. He thought that he was fortunate. Although he was injured, he hadn't been caught and managed to bring back money. He didn't know how long it would take Tangtang to learn to dance and sing, and become an elegant young lady.

He checked the time. It was time to go to work.

(Editors' Note: In this issue, Deborah Stanish interviews Hao Jingfang.)

© 2015 Hao Jingfang


Evernote helps you remember everything and get organized effortlessly. Download Evernote.

Monday, August 15, 2016

尴尬的《大鱼·海棠》:中国动漫的传统文化焦虑


尴尬的《大鱼·海棠》:中国动漫的传统文化焦虑

"传统文化"不能当做法宝贴在前额上,作为影人和受众用来抵挡假想敌人的符纸一张

编按:本文最早以"借力传统文化的《大鱼·海棠》,为何成了浮华空洞的命题作文"为题,载于澎湃新闻"思想市场"栏目,经作者授权,由《端传媒》编修转载。

动画电影《大鱼.海棠》。官方网页图片

中国动画的话题之作,十二年磨一剑的《大鱼·海棠》,只用了两天时间就从朱砂痣变成了墙上一抹蚊子血。两位导演梁旋和张春,因2004年制作 Flash 短片《大·海》一拍即合,次年成立"彼岸天"公司,制作精美样片获得公众关注。此后电影状况频出,多次跳票:2010年与上海文广公司合作破裂;2013年以158万元创下众筹融资记录,并获得光线影业投资;再由2D转制3D……105分钟的动画长片终于在2016年7月"千呼万唤始出来"。

这中间,观众对两位新人导演的热情起起落落,但在《喜羊羊》、《熊出没》等制作粗糙,受众限于低龄的商业大电影映衬下,据说融会了《逍遥游》、《山海经》的《大鱼·海棠》还是被舆论塑造为中国"国漫崛起"的希望所在。

然而,尽管《大鱼海棠》6.6的豆瓣评分,仍高于绝大多数适合寒暑假"亲子沟通感情"的所谓"国漫"。但这个分数似乎已经反映出,观众们经历了超长战线的情怀营销、吊足胃口的两版预告片和轰轰烈烈的众筹(大众集资)之后,对动画成品相当不满。上映第三天,替电影唱红脸的评论文章才姗姗来迟。而在此之前,长长短短的差评已经对后来者的观影体验产生了决定影响。

在编剧梁旋眼中,这是一部关于"责任与守护"的电影,女孩"椿"生活在大海之下的神界中,和其他人一起司掌海面上世界的自然规律。为了挽回因救她而死的陌生人类少年,她选择付出半条性命,甘冒天谴养大少年灵魂幻化的小鱼"鲲"。青梅竹马的神界男孩"湫"一直帮助着她,为助她成功强行开启海天之门,导致海水倒灌,神界涂炭。"椿"为救众生,自杀化为海棠堵住洪水,却因"湫"同样用性命交换而复活。影片最后,"湫"燃烧自己将"椿"和"鲲"送回了人间,他们以人类的身体如亚当夏娃般重新相遇。

然而在阅尽类型片套路的观众眼里,这不过是一个"狗血"的三角恋老套故事,包裹在"传统文化"的精致糖衣里,他们指责女主角是"绿茶婊"、"白莲花"。然而,简单套用大陆流行文化中的污名标签,评价一个不自居于此话语体系内的故事,过于粗暴。更有趣的,其实是这层"糖衣"——为什么"传统文化"会成为《大鱼·海棠》的主打牌,被寄予"国漫崛起"的厚望?

"传统文化"、童年回忆与失落的自信

不难发现,能够引起"国漫"热议的中国动画,常标榜自身的传统文化底蕴。当然,在时空上为"传统文化"这个不免带有中心论和浪漫主义色彩的词划定一个公认的范围,几乎不可能。但我们仍可以列举一些最为可能的资源:上古神话、诗骚、儒道百家、八仙故事、《三国》、《西游》、《聊斋》……近年来对《西游》题材的接力式改编即是一例。

2015年的现象级动画电影《大圣归来》,讲述孙悟空和唐僧前世江流儿的因缘,在资金限制和缺乏前期宣传的情况下低开高走,率先引起"国漫讨论"。其后,2016年初的《小门神》、获得动画短片罕见知名度的《海公子》、近两年重被翻出来的老片《山水情》都证明了:想和"国漫"二字沾边,传统文化元素可以说是必过之关。

观众如此看重传统文化题材,近在眼前的原因是国产美术片留下的美好回忆。直到九十年代后期,中央电视台第六台(电影频道)每晚仍会播出主要由上海美术电影制片厂制作的经典美术片:《大闹天宫》、《小蝌蚪找妈妈》、《阿凡提》、《九色鹿》、《天书奇谭》……这些萤幕经典,是60后到90后中国人共同的童年美学启蒙。它们化用古典文学、民间传说以及水墨、剪纸、壁画等中国传统美术技法和造型元素,深受观众好评,在国际电影界也有很高声誉。

可惜,1999年的《宝莲灯》后,高成本、高难度的"剧场版"已成动画大势所趋,面临经费短缺、定位困难、2D转3D技术障碍等问题的上美,少有后继佳作。

传承的断裂放大了怀旧情结,使得前辈之作成为想象新国漫的标杆。而这一期待又伴随着"先前也阔过"的今昔对比焦虑。颓废和进步总是一体两面。对深受近代以来社会进化论影响,有"进步"紧迫感,又仍然有"世风日下人心不古"复古倾向的中国人来说,历史教科书上近代中国没落的前车之鉴,可谓"今不如昔"的恐惧原型。

于是,国漫必须"崛起",因为"崛起"其实是"复兴"的同义词。从小接受的民族主义教育让中国人习惯于把一切领域的表现水准都升华,与国家的国际地位、历史命运紧密联系。因而国漫、国足或者国产奶粉的困境,时常被渲染得好像又到了"最危机的时候"。

与此对应的,是中国人对产业成熟的美漫、日漫,怀有某种文化入侵论式的隐隐不安。《大圣归来》上映时,这一倾向很明显:《大圣》能否代表国漫崛起?这一问题在网络参与度极高的实际讨论中,被置换为"《大圣》能否比得过日漫?"或"《大圣》是否抄袭了日漫?"

在论辩中,乐观者列举种种不输日漫的要素:精美、热血、细节丰富;悲观者则指出相比日漫,《大圣》剧情单薄、叙事模式和动作上充斥著借鉴。随着讨论逐渐激化,后者几乎难逃"崇洋媚外"、"亲日不爱国"的指责,可见动漫讨论背后最根本的民族主义动机。而现在,在《大鱼·海棠》的影评中,热点也几乎和上述完全相同。

"传统文化"的纠葛,与动漫题材的选择

很自然,要拍代表"中国水平"的动漫,就要在内容、形式、尤其是精神价值上集中体现中国特色。恰如很多异乡客漂到了大都市,会比原来更乐于"表演"自己的乡音和乡俗。外界刻板印象的标签,在庞杂多元大环境中可以为个体带来价值层面的安全感──"至少我是独特的。"同样,文化独特性仿佛可以印证影片的独创性,担保其免受(或者少受)抄袭指责。

"国漫"概念乍听很有"国际视野"。但其创作和评论,往往像是预设了奥斯卡评审团坐在下面作为理想观众。在影片中展示瑰丽璀璨的传统文化,就如殷勤的主人向重要的客人展示家当。表现中国的特别,似乎就能印证中国动漫/电影的特别,以此缓解对"崛起"、"复兴"的焦虑。认真来说,被滥用的"国际视野"一词,常常指的就是西方凝视的自觉内化:有针对性地迎合对方他者化的想像(神秘瑰丽或者衰朽落后)来推销自身。

在八九十年代夺得国际大奖的兴奋过后,很多中国人转而批评《大红灯笼高高挂》、《菊豆》、《霸王别姬》等"第五代导演"三十年前打开国际市场的第一批电影,认为他们专事揭传统文化疮疤以迎合评审会口味,在"国际视野"中,功利地"把自我他者化"(变成他人目光下的审视对象)了。而如今的"秀家当",和当年的"揭疮疤"有着类似的实际功能,只是映射出相反的时代心态:在八十年代普遍的"文化反思"热潮中,"第五代导演"的创作动机有对外展示,更有对内的讨论、批判,不能被"国际视野"单纯涵盖。但他们夺奖之路上的"成功",却在今天被当做经验继承下来——"中国的才是世界的"。

抛开外部的审视,"国漫"也被赋予了弘扬、传承民族精神的义务。自孔子和柏拉图时代的"教化论"以来,高等的艺术常常要表现崇高主题,教化万民或为城邦培养合格公民。尽管这一观念太过精英,但"为人生而艺术"的现世关怀,最后总是要落到"寓教于乐"上。默认以青少年为主要受众的动漫,自然更是如此。

而"传统文化"这个现代概念,自诞生起就作为民族精神的同义词,被视为民族命运的决定因素。二十世纪初的"打倒孔家店"、"整理国故"以及相继的"保存国粹";六十年代的"破四旧";八十年代中后期继"反封建"后的传统文化大反思和"寻根潮",都说明现代以来的中国民族主义,总是以传统和反传统姿态交替进行。

而这之中,传统文化的重要地位又来自于传统-现代、中国-西方这两对二元对立结构——第一对其实是第二对的变体。在80年代李泽厚等引领的"新启蒙"思潮中,中国向西方学习,将传统改造为现代成为发展的唯一路径。而今天,中国遭遇想象中的西方,和泥沙俱下汹涌而来的不那么浪漫的现代化,传统文化又成了全球化中同西方抗衡,凝聚民族认同的重要资源。看似自负的文化沙文主义背后,是在被迫的急速前进中担心迷失、担心没有退路的自我保护。

另外,比起讲一个神秘、动人的古老故事,中国人其实很难想象在院线上映的动画长片里轰轰烈烈、严肃认真地讲一个现代故事。现阶段为数不多的"国漫",内容是匮乏的,擅长表现史诗般的宏大场面,但像校园、都市、职业、科幻等很多平凡、日常和琐碎的主题,都没有表达经验。此外,中国尽管千呼万唤,但仍然没有动漫分级制度,所有作品默认全年龄向,也就是实际上的低年龄向。

因此,承载"传统文化"的"国漫",需要小心翼翼承担它启蒙教化的责任,而如果追求现实的"深度",就会涉及那些带着"乖孩子"共同观影的家长不希望出现的内容。传统文化包裹下的古代故事或神怪故事,则安全得多,《小门神》可以借神仙下岗危机,幽默、欢快而委婉地戳一下现实肋骨,但也就仅此而已。

买椟还珠的动漫电影,被当做工具的"传统文化"

回到《大鱼·海棠》,它宏大、精致而风格化的视觉效果,无论横向、纵向比较,其实都不输于人,在画面元素的丰富性上,较《大圣归来》又上了一个台阶。虽然世界观是虚构的,但这个小世界富有质感而处处用心,导演甚至在片尾字幕列上了电影的"参考文献"。

不过,正如中学生的作文,有了华丽的辞藻、丰富的典故,和一些结构上的巧思,只要离题不太远,总能是一等文。但同时,它像是那种课程学习极度刻苦,熟悉得分要点,却缺少课外阅读的"好学生"写出的一等文:捧着工具书啃了大量诗词典故成语素材,然而浮皮潦草,一知半解,很多典故只知道主角一个响亮的名字,于是便把它们拼在一起,用华丽的排比句营造一种马赛克拼贴般的梦幻效果,来代替层层推进的逻辑叙述。仿佛不管作文主题是什么,先祭出屈原、司马迁、曹雪芹、鲁迅这些大咖就足以压阵。但这些被强行召唤的神灵,除了聚在一起表达"中华传统文化博大精深",对于文章帮助有限——形式与内容,内容与神韵严重脱节,这就是诸如《大鱼·海棠》之类的动画给人的感觉。

以主角和主题为例:以"椿"、"湫"为名的女主、男二,除了名字,和"八千岁为一春,八千岁为一秋"的"大椿"并无精神关系。"椿"的爷爷是上古圣哲、妈妈是清朝仕女、自己像个民国女学生。她"一生只养一条鱼"的行为可以用执念解释,用羁绊解释,但唯独不能用《逍遥游》来解释——她太"数数然"了。

在这个故事中,所有"归墟"、"南冥"、"鲲鹏"、"大椿",都只是被召来替"传统文化"接受礼拜的"尸",而不是它的"神":一个关于"守护"和"责任"的故事,怎么能用一套道家的语言来讲呢?"寂漠无形,变化无常,死与,生与?天地并与,神明往与?"若主角有半分庄子的觉悟,开场十分钟就相忘于江湖了。导演大动干戈地动用《山海经》、《逍遥游》这些宏大厚重的典籍搭建一个世界,似有"买椟还珠"之嫌。

而在动漫的世界设定上,按照通常的牌路,这个藏身海洋之下,掌握着人间秘密的世界与人间构成镜像关系,其中应该有对人间社会的隐喻或寄托。主角化身的巡游人间的大红海豚穿梭两界,更如同上帝派出考察善恶的天使,可以获得间离视角。看预告片的时候,笔者本以为土楼围屋代表着某种傅柯式的监视装置,象征着这个世界的保守和森严。但正片中,海下的社会仅是"一群人站在一起"。导演将有关于爱情(或者守护)的关怀寄托在主角身上,除此之外的大部分人物都是推进叙事、充实视觉场景的道具。

这一切并不奇怪,"传统文化"这个词,时间上充满了现代的线性史观,空间上包含著民族﹣国家的共同体想像,这两者使得它在中国-西方、传统-现代的二元对立结构中,几乎本能被唤起。

然而,在充满著追赶焦虑的二十世纪,经历文化断裂的中国,无暇为其匆匆塞入"传统文化"百宝箱的一大堆东西建立一套有逻辑、有历史纵深的主体叙事;无暇像现代欧洲大陆那样,将"classics"压缩还原为各个时代、各种潮流、各种冲突相互关联的结构,而一直保持著弱者面对强者注视时的应激倾向,把自我当成一整块被凝视的对象,从而"自我他者化"。这种倾向结合大国的文化自负,只能制造出土文物般脱离了原生语境的奇观,发出远古传来的支离破碎的声音。

电影和其他文化产品,都不反对奇观,但没有主体性和叙事性的奇观,不再是内部矛盾运动著的生命有机体,它不再区分不同渊源流派、不同民族风格,甚至不再区分好坏——当淫祀已经成为时尚,"伏羲班"遍地开花,《弟子规》成为教子宝典,我们突然想起,太久没在主流表述中听到过"取其精华去其糟粕"了,因为传统文化被当做工具,而相比工具价值,以上这些不重要——被匆忙安置于神坛的塑像只有一个界限模糊的整体,整体之下就是粘合在一起的符号碎片:鲲鹏、大椿、帝江、凤凰、土楼、民国风……模糊和不健全使得这个整体不能动作,只能履行其"他者化"神坛上单一的职责。这团缺乏形状的碎片不得不进一步巩固既存的中国﹣西方、传统﹣现代二元对立,用这些外骨骼来撑起自身的存在意义。全球化与现代化的焦虑,对传统的热衷互相缠绕。

这里或许有一个恶性循环:当传统文化成为工具性的迫切需求,对概念本身的梳理、反思和理解很容易落在后面,缺乏内涵的空洞外壳无法真正满足需求,反而因为强化了危机而触发更迫切的工具性需求。

其实,"传统文化"需要的不是一浪高过一浪,或者文化自负,或者自我悲情的呼号,因为被呼唤的是什么都尚未厘清。需要的,是将语焉不详的整体和光怪陆离的碎片还原为有血有肉,历史地存在过的文化,还原为有内在逻辑,有情感冲动,可以对话的有机体。

只有这样,中国的"国漫"和其他想要表现传统文化又力求独立世界观的文化产品,才能让传统文化和自己都有呼吸生长、表现创造力的空间;希望从传统文化中汲取营养的文化产业,才能走出二元对立的死循环,以真正有机、多元的文化整体性来显示"文"已臻"化"境的自信从容,而不是紧紧抓住"传统文化"的法宝贴在前额上,作为影人和受众用来抵挡假想敌人的符纸一张。

(陈子丰,北京大学中文系博士生,关注文化社会学)

  • China1
    截取一段:從小接受的民族主義教育讓中國人習慣於把一切領域的表現水準都昇華,與國家的國際地位、歷史命運緊密聯繫。
  • xingchen
    看過這麼多評論國漫的文章,這篇才真是功底深厚。傳統文化在發展時,遇見焦慮幾乎是必然的,我們希望展現的自我形象,永遠也離不開心中預設的「他者」,這也可以解釋為何在上世紀七十年代,李小龍幾乎代表了西方人眼中的中國人,而我們一直以撕掉「東亞病夫」的烙印而自豪。同時在塑造自我形象完成後的一瞬間,這一「客體」就已脫離了創作人的控制:選取何種角度、出於何種目的的解讀,都無法離開解讀者的自身背景。這也說明了為什麼帶有傳統文化元素的作品,一經面世總能引起不小的爭議。一方面作為「中國傳統文化的承襲者」,觀眾是會不自覺地將自己代入「代表者」角色的,維護或批判,都是以主人翁的心態;另一方面,作為代表中國傳統文化的作品,一旦走出去,它所承載的內涵及期望,遠遠大過創作者的預期。中國傳統文化的表現、繼承、光大形式,當然不可能靠一部全民關注的國漫來代表。如何內化經典,而不是「有形無神」,使「傳統文化」不再成為簡單的符號,而確確實實地存在所指,才是引發熱潮的國漫出現的真正意義。

Evernote helps you remember everything and get organized effortlessly. Download Evernote.

这位耶鲁美女老师说,中国学生写作习惯恰恰美国大学最忌讳


这位耶鲁美女老师说,中国学生写作习惯恰恰美国大学最忌讳

2016-07-19 23:14:31
声明:本文由入驻搜狐公众平台的作者撰写,除搜狐官方账号外,观点仅代表作者本人,不代表搜狐立场。举报
  

  写作课(essay writing)是美国顶尖大学博雅教育的基础课程,是本科生在深入专业领域学习之前必不可少的批判性思维和逻辑表达训练。他们的写作课都教些什么?这里的"写作"与我们通常所说的"写作"是不是一回事?带着这些疑问,外滩君专访了耶鲁大学本科写作课老师Emily Ulrich。Emily不仅介绍了essay写作的要点和训练方式,还特别为想提高写作能力的中国学生提出了建议。

文 | 吴妍娇 摄影 | 洪宇哲

编辑 | 闻琛

  周五的午后,外滩君在古象酒店见到了传说中的耶鲁超级文学学霸Emily老师,虽不是第一眼美女,但定睛一看竟有几分神似安吉丽娜·朱莉,没有了朱莉的招牌式迷人大嘴,脸上的笑容却依旧动人。

  Emily是土生土长的美国人,也曾在欧洲待过数年。本科毕业于达特茅斯学院,主修历史和语言学。后又进入伦敦国王学院深造,获得了英文文学硕士学位。回到美国后,她投身于中世纪文学和历史的研究,获得了耶鲁大学的中世纪研究文学硕士和哲学硕士学位。

  目前,Emily在耶鲁继续着她钟爱的中世纪文学研究,并攻读Ph. D学位。不过在研究之外,她还有另一个身份:教授耶鲁本科生写作课,尤其是大一新生的学术写作入门。

  在她看来,写作之所以在美国高校的课程中有如此重要的地位,几乎每门课程都需要撰写essay,和美国高校提倡"博雅教育"(Liberal Arts Education)密不可分。博雅教育培养的是全面发展的思想者和世界公民,提倡学生博览各类学科,了解多种思路和方法,拥有自由的思想。而Liberal一词本身也代表了学生以文字阐述自己思想的能力。

  "读写能力是所有教育的基础,也是最难的一种抽象的批判性思维。"它不仅与博雅教育的哲学内涵相呼应,从现实角度来看,学术写作也的确是众多课程的主要考核形式,这也就是为什么美国顶尖高校基本都会要求学生在刚入大学时就选修一些与写作相关的课程,因为从高中时期针对客观事实的观点型写作到大学时期提倡个人创新发现的研究型写作,这其中有着巨大的跨越。

  和外滩君交流时,Emily老师思维敏捷、语速飞快,一度让我深感follow不上她的节奏。不过转念一想也便释然,似乎一个牛气的耶鲁写作课老师本就该有这般自信的姿态?

B=外滩教育 E=Emily

  1

  学术写作到底有多难?

  B:学术写作与一般写作形式有何不同?

  E:两者的不同之处主要有两个方面:

  第一,学术写作是通过和某一领域的其他专家的交流而被建构起来的,你会假设你的读者对某个话题感兴趣,而且他们想要知道更多,然后你把你自己的发现融入这个领域其他现存的发现之中。

  我想举个比较有意思的例子,在《指环王》中有一种神秘的生物——树人。他们在书中相当有喜剧色彩,因为他们是树,所以讲话特别慢。而周遭充斥着战争和动荡,然后你看到这些树人,他们也在进行一场权力的斗争,但是他们语速极慢,可能5个小时只能说一句话。而在我看来,学术写作就像树人,整个发表的过程特别慢,是一场非常严谨的学术交流,但不管怎么说,它依然是一场对话,不是某个定论,学习如何融入这样一场学术对话是必经之途。

  第二个不同之处其实包含两点。首先,是对原创性研究的强调。你需要去发现一些别人未发现过的数据,从而去传递一些真相。我们对真相的求索应该是永不停止的,因为我们在不断地发现新的信息。

  其次,进行有说服力的论证的确是一门艺术。论证中应该包含你认为最佳的信息,但是对于那些和你的观点相左的信息,你也需要去阐明为什么它们是无关紧要的,它们如何服务于你的中心思想句。整个论证的过程不仅要关注你的论点,还要辐射更大的学术背景,这也是学术写作的独特之处。

  2

  学术写作的三座大山:一手研究、文本细读、批判性思维

  B:你会如何训练学生做研究?

  E:我给学生们强调最多的,就是一手资料和二手资料的区别。二手资料指的是对某个对象已有分析的资料,一手资料则是指最原始的资料。举个例子,如果说《人权法案》是一手资料,那二手资料可能就是有关《人权法案》的各种书籍。这其中的区别非常重要,一个是从未经过过滤的对象,另外一个则是通过某种筛选的历史时期。

  在大学阶段,我们会鼓励学生做一手研究。大多数刚升入大学的学生都只做过二手研究,假设他们研究的是《人权法案》,他们会读很多相关的书,然后写一篇论文。但在大学,我们会让学生研究《人权法案》本身,然后形成属于自己的二手资料。因此我在教学生的时候会说,无论你们对什么话题领域感兴趣,你们都要至少找到一份一手资料,而且关注的点要尽量小,否则的话你们需要处理的数据会太多,然后基于你找到的这个一手资料去写你的论文。

  举个例子,如果你对美国的民权运动感兴趣,那么你需要找到某次集会中的某个发言,或是一份报纸上的某一篇报道,或是一幅图片比如一张海报,我需要你去寻找任何能够阐述那个年代的元素。我发现学生们特别有干劲,因为他们在做一些原创的发现,他们在用新的材料去回答过去的问题。我教他们去发现各种可能,去观察文章的措辞、报纸上的字体,是如何和当时的时代背景相呼应的,而这就是研究。

  B:什么是"文本细读"?为何要训练这种技能?

  E:"文本细读"实际上是中国学生觉得最难的部分。你需要尽可能地慢下来,不仅要看到文本(一个短语、句子)的字面意思(尤其是在文学作品中,当然这个技能在除了英语学科以外的其他领域也同样适用),还要不断地深入挖掘,找到作者想要表达的更深一层次的含义,除此之外,还需要辨别出在整部作品中反复出现的手法和模式。

  再举个例子,我让学生读丹尼尔· 凯斯的经典之作《献给阿尔吉农的花束》,这本书在美国的中学和高中的书单中经常出现。全书讲述的是一个特别愚笨的人,做了一个手术,突然变得特别聪慧,然而变聪明的代价是,大脑会退化得很快。这是一本非常优秀的科幻作品。

  在这部作品中有一个桥段,当主人公已经变得足够智慧了,他意识到他原本认为是朋友的人不再是他的朋友了。当他愚笨的时候,他认为他的朋友们都很爱他,他们笑是因为开心;而当他变聪明了以后,他终于明白这些人是在取笑他,而不是和他一起笑。

  为了形容主人公的这种震惊和羞耻,书中这样写道:"我觉得自己像什么都没穿一样,我想要找个地方躲起来,我觉得万分羞耻。"而在西方文学中,这个形容显然和圣经中伊甸园的故事异曲同工,亚当和夏娃在误食禁果以后对上帝说他们感到羞耻,想要躲起来,这是西方文化中形容人类失去天真的最为经典的寓言。

  那么说回到"文本细读",它要求读者能够发现这处形容和圣经语言的共鸣,然后去思考这种圣经语言对我们社会的影响,失去天真就永远不能回归天堂。因此现在我们知道,书中不仅仅在说一种尴尬的处境,还让我们思考失去天真的悲剧,它是如何去改变整个故事的走向,当主人公在书的最后又一次失去智慧的时候,是否悲剧仍在继续呢?还是他过去那种虽然愚笨却很开心的状态被突如其来的聪慧彻底毁掉了呢?你会去思考,得到智慧这件事情到底是一种善意还是罪恶?

  这就是"文本细读"的精髓,它从文本的原始含义出发,观察它与更大主题的共鸣,然后利用这种共鸣去重新解读原来的对象。这种做法同样适用于研究历史、艺术史或者社会科学等学科。

  不过,"文本细读"的确是一项比较难习得的技能。它使你的思维过程变得复杂,而且这项技能对于每个人的人生都很重要,甚至对于任何需要创造力的岗位都是必须的。比如你要懂得去读出商业报告中的深层含义,你要学会去解读新闻。我想这也是为什么博雅教育会如此受追捧的原因。假设在职场上有两个候选人,一个拥有博雅教育的技能背景,另一个没有,你一定会选择前者,因为前者会始终保有创新精神。

  B:你会如何训练学生的批判性思维技能?

  E:写作的美好在于,你总有机会逼大家去更深入地思考,通常我会让学生说出某篇论文的中心论点,他们经常会不可避免地犯错,因为在任何复杂的论文里,都会有很多论点,问题在于你如何发现某个可以概述其他内容的论点,这就是批判性思维的训练,因为你让学生把各层的论点按照等级排列,学会总结,不遗漏重要的部分,让他们明白在总结中需要精细到怎样的程度。这些都是非常复杂的思考过程。

  我有个最好的例子,当我让学生去修改他们的论文时,我会再三强调一些严格的规则,让学生仔细阅读论文,改正这些地方,然后上交给我。他们一开始会满怀希望地动手修改,完成checklist上的所有事,然后你只要等个15到20分钟,你就会发现他们脸上那种惊恐的表情,他们会突然发现自己的句子好像空无一物,根本没有写出他们想要表达的东西。事实上,任何经常写作的人都会经历这一过程,就像一件毛衣,你拉出一根毛线,整件毛衣就散架了。

  这也就是为什么批判性思维特别重要的原因,因为当你想要传达你的观点的时候,所有有关这个观点的缺陷全都会凸显出来,而这的确让人无比抓狂。我鼓励一个学生小心翼翼地对待他们的所思所想,实际上是让他们诚实地面对自己,直面他们写下的各种不符合逻辑的胡话,这个过程经历得越多,他们未来犯错的几率就越小。所以在写作中不断地修改、编辑甚至重写,才能造就一个真正优秀的批判性作者。

  3

  读什么都行,让文字流淌过你的身体

  B:你会推荐你的学生阅读什么书籍?

  E:对于英语非母语的学生来说,尽可能地多读书是熟练写作的最好方式。而阅读本应该充满乐趣才对。如果可以单纯地享受阅读,你就已经在做一件非常有意义的事了。因为你可以拓展自己的词汇量,提升你的句式,使一些约定俗成的东西内化为写作习惯,发现书面语和口头语之间的不同,所以基本上我的推荐是百无禁忌的。

  其实无所谓你读什么、读多少,如果你能够培养阅读习惯,每天坚持阅读1小时,而不是整天坐着看电视,通过几年的积累,那就是无数个小时的阅读。而且你无法在这个过程中作弊,唯一的方法就是在一段很长的时间里,每天坚持阅读一点点,比如你喜欢简·奥斯汀的小说,那就去读,如果你特别喜欢科幻小说,也可以去读。你不一定非得读莎士比亚,虽然很多人可能想读,但在我看来,只要读起来就可以。

  B:有什么特别的阅读方法吗?

  E:如果你读的是学术论文,你想学习前辈们是如何去论证的,我会建议做三件事:划出主要的论点,划出首次提出论点后每次作者重申论点的部分,划出作者使用的不同种类的论据,然后观察其中的模式。每次我在课堂上给我的学生发铅笔,让他们做这些的时候,他们都觉得太小儿科了,但通过这样的分解,去观察作者的论点是如何被传达的,这是我所认为的最好的学习方法。

  而如果是一般性的被动阅读,就让那些文字肆意地流淌过你的身体,很多人可能都有这样的经历,一开始读一本外文书会特别兴奋地查阅每个生词,而半小时之后就不得不放弃了,因为工作量实在太大。而我的经验是,继续读下去,即使遇到不认识的单词,只要基本的情节可以理解,就一直读下去。你会发现,如果就这样一直读下去,实际上可以学到更多。

  4

  中国式写作的bug

  B:你觉得中国学生的写作水平和批判性思维水平怎么样?

  E:事实上,一篇好的中文论文和英文论文的标准几乎是完全相反的,美式写作偏爱简短、干净的句子,段落篇幅也比较短,每一段只讲一个中心观点,所有观点都按照逻辑来排列。也许是因为中文写作鼓励这种方式,中国学生似乎都在拼命地寻找更多表达方式去表达同一个想法,他们使用很多繁复的词汇,写冗长又饱含诗意的句子。

  事实上,我所研究的中世纪文学也有这种特点。如果你了解你的话题,你知道你要表达什么,而且它是正确无误的,那你就可以使用多种方式来表达一个意思。而你所展示出来的是一种掌控一切的姿态,不仅是这个话题本身,还有各种表达方式。这也是打动读者的技巧。

  不过,在美国人眼中,这相当于在说:不要关注我的想法,看我华丽的辞藻。这反而会被解读为一种让人分神的花哨,而非优势。中国学生会花很多时间去查字典,小心地酝酿语言,写华丽的长句,而我会对他们说:缩短!缩短!缩短!保持最简单、最直接的表达方式。

  另一方面,"文本细读"肯定也是一个大问题。中国学生从来没有接触过这样的思考和阅读方式,但这对于美国教育而言却是极为核心的技能,包括做研究和写作。刚一开始让学生自己去尝试的确是很难的,但经过整个大学四年的集中训练,学生的写作能力相较高中阶段会有一个巨大的飞跃。

  以下是Emily老师推荐的写作训练相关书籍,之后她会在外滩教育微信群开展公开课,敬请期待!

  BOOKS

  1. The Norton Reader

  这本书被耶鲁新生广泛传读。书中都是一些精简的非小说类的小故事,文笔很好。这样只需要每天抽空读一两个小故事,潜意识中你将慢慢地内化和模仿出作者的写作水平。有研究显示,对美国高中生来说,这样的阅读可以有效帮助学生提升英语的SAT成绩。

  The Elements of Style

  

  本书精炼了美国论文写作的犀利技巧,是美国大学新生的必读书目之一。

  3. The Craft of Research

  如果你对研究类论文感兴趣,这本书可以帮助你提高研究技能和阐述研究结果的水平。

  "超级教师报告"相关阅读

  好的戏剧教育能丰富孩子对世界的理解,找到真实的自己

  国际学校里一堂好的中文课,绝不该是对外汉语的味道任教第二年就带出8个IB满分,这位学霸老师的秘诀居然是讲段子?

点击关键字阅读2000+篇优质文章

|少年书房||数学思想

小留学生日记|批判性思维

钢琴课酷老师写作课牛娃录排行榜

  喜欢就点赞

  内容转载自公众号

  

  外滩教育

  了解更多


Evernote helps you remember everything and get organized effortlessly. Download Evernote.

LRB · Mark Ford · I gotta use words: Eliot speaks in tongues


I gotta use words

Mark Ford

  • BuyThe Poems of T.S. Eliot: Volume I: Collected & Uncollected Poems edited by Christopher Ricks and Jim McCue
    Faber, 1311 pp, £40.00, November 2015, ISBN 978 0 571 23870 5
  • The Poems of T.S. Eliot: Volume II: Practical Cats & Further Verses edited by Christopher Ricks and Jim McCue
    Faber, 667 pp, £40.00, November 2015, ISBN 978 0 571 23371 7

The first person to annotate a poem by T.S. Eliot was T.S. Eliot. His notes on The Waste Land (1922) were composed partly so that his 433-line poem could be issued by his American publishers Boni & Liveright as a book, and partly, as he recalled in 'The Frontiers of Criticism' (1956), 'with a view to spiking the guns of critics of my earlier poems who had accused me of plagiarism'. 'Not only the title,' Eliot observed in his introductory paragraph to The Waste Land's notes,

but the plan and a good deal of the incidental symbolism of the poem were suggested by Miss Jessie L. Weston's book on the Grail legend: From Ritual to Romance (Cambridge). Indeed, so deeply am I indebted, Miss Weston's book will elucidate the difficulties of the poem much better than my notes can do; and I recommend it (apart from the great interest of the book itself) to any who think such elucidation of the poem worth the trouble.

In these seemingly sober, useful, self-deprecating sentences lurks the MacGuffin, to borrow Alfred Hitchcock's term, that reaches its epic, mind-boggling climax in the publication, nearly a century on, of Faber's two all-comprehending new tomes, edited by Christopher Ricks and Jim McCue. The editors promise to 'elucidate the difficulties' of Eliot's work by tracing every possible verbal overlap between the words used in his poems and the words used by other writers, both famous and obscure, in texts that range from Dante's Divine Comedy to an anonymous scribe's record of the Acts and Resolutions of the 29th General Assembly of Iowa (1902).

The lines of Eliot's that most often occurred to me as I worked my way through these thousand or so pages of commentary (set in 10-point type) are from Sweeney Agonistes. In the course of his narrative about a man who 'did a girl in', and then kept her body in a bath with a gallon of Lysol, Sweeney explains that the murderer would periodically visit him:

sweeney: He used to come and see me sometimes
I'd give him a drink and cheer him up.

doris: Cheer him up?

dusty:                      Cheer him up?

sweeney: Well here again that don't apply
But I've gotta use words when I talk to you.

One of the side effects of reading through this edition's extraordinarily wide-ranging and inclusive notes is the periodical rising of a Sweeney-like urge to declare: 'That don't apply.' Like Sweeney, every poem has got to use words, and those words will also necessarily have been used in the work of earlier or contemporary writers.

To begin at the very beginning: is there a meaningful relationship between 'Let us go then …' (the opening words of 'The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock'), and the phrase 'Let us go now …' which occurs in Chapter 40 of Daniel Deronda (with 'street' and 'sky' later in the paragraph); between 'When the evening is spread out against the sky' (line 2 of 'Prufrock') and Thomas Hardy's 'forms there flung/Against the sky' ('The Abbey Mason'); between 'certain half-deserted streets' (line 4 of 'Prufrock') and 'he sought out a certain street and number' in Chapter 20 of Little Dorrit; or, moving beyond literature, between that phrase and the recording of a payment made to 'R.D. Bennett, for sprinkling a certain street' in the aforementioned Acts and Resolutions of the 29th General Assembly of Iowa; between Prufrock's 'overwhelming question' (line 10) and the observation in Chapter 23 of James Fenimore Cooper's The Pioneers that 'The whole company were a good deal astounded with this overwhelming question'?

Certainly Eliot's mind was a vast, labyrinthine echo chamber, and perhaps more than any other canonical poet of the English language, with the possible exception of his great antagonist John Milton, he was conscious of the previous uses by other writers of the words he deployed in his poems. But what exactly is the difference, one can't help wondering while reading such notes, between an interesting allusion or echo and a mere verbal coincidence? And where should limits be set for the recording of these echoes or coincidences in the age of the internet, when it's possible to pursue any phrase ad infinitum? Should notes in a scholarly edition aspire to the condition of an entry in the OED? Anyone with an interest in Eliot will be grateful for, and marvel at, the truly extraordinary knowledge of all things Eliotic that underpins these volumes, but – to get my quibble out of the way early, so that I can praise the numerous virtues of this edition with a clear conscience – it is not always easy to discern the value of the links the editors posit between Eliot's words and the analogous phrases, drawn from a bewildering array of writers, presented for comparison in the commentary.

Those first ten lines of 'Prufrock', for instance, elicit, as well as the citations I've already mentioned, quotations from Jules Laforgue, W.E. Henley, Théophile Gautier, Russell S. Fowler (author of The Operating Room and the Patient, a 1906 book which includes a reference to 'anaesthetic tables'), William James, James Thomson, William Acton, Charles-Louis Philippe, W.R. Burnett (a crime novelist in whose High Sierra – published in 1940 – the phrase 'She was … a one-night-stand type' occurs), Edward Winslow Martin (author of The Secrets of the Great City, 1868, which mentions 'cheap hotels'), the London Baedeker, Cooper's The Prairie and Hamlet's 'overwhelming question' – '"To be, or not to be, that is the question." Perhaps also OED 6: "to pop the question (slang or colloq.), to propose marriage" (1725)'. In addition, the notes on these ten lines draw our attention to eight other Eliot poems, as well as including quotations from The Cocktail Party and a number of his essays and letters. It's worth remarking at the very least that the parameters established for this edition constitute a new frontier in the use of notes to record verbal echoes and overlaps, as well as to include tangential facts. The quote from The Prairie, for instance, is adduced because Eliot always sounds the final 't' in 'restaurants' in his various recorded readings of 'Prufrock'; 'OED,' the editors add, 'gives a pronunciation in which it is not sounded, and the spelling of its first citation, from Fenimore Cooper, 1827, points to the French derivation: "At the most renowned of the Parisian restaurans".' This is a good instance of the sort of knowledge you will pick up from Ricks and McCue's commentary as an unexpected bonus. It illustrates their generous wish to impart as much information as possible, and while their method throws up all manner of fascinating trouvailles, surely even the most devoted Eliot scholars will occasionally find themselves scratching their heads when ordinary words such as 'toast' ('the taking of a toast and tea') are glossed by an OED definition – 'Bread so browned by fire, electric heat etc.' The editors' kitchen-sink approach to annotation makes even Longman editions, such as Ricks's own wonderful three-volume edition of Tennyson – who published an awful lot more poetry than Eliot – seem modest by comparison.

Modernist writing often foregrounded in unignorable ways the issues raised in the opening sentences of Eliot's notes to The Waste Land. The difficulties presented through his use of allusions and source materials required elucidation by reference to other books, and readers had to be persuaded that getting to grips with an anthropological text on medieval legends in order to understand the poem that it supposedly inspired was 'worth the trouble'. On occasion Eliot himself expressed remorse for having kickstarted the business of allusion-hunting with his 'bogus scholarship', while conceding that the poem and its notes were wed for ever: 'I have sometimes thought of getting rid of these notes; but now they can never be unstuck. They have had almost greater popularity than the poem itself – anyone who bought my book of poems, and found that the notes to The Waste Land were not in it, would demand his money back.' Maybe so, but Eliot's notes hardly offer a reader-friendly exposition of the poem's mysteries: they assume proficiency in French, Italian, Latin and German, and they struck Arnold Bennett, whose help Eliot sought while he was at work on Sweeney Agonistes, as a spoof: 'I said to him,' Bennett recorded in his Journals, '"I want to ask you a question. It isn't an insult. Were the notes to Wastelands a lark or serious? I thought they were a skit." He said that they were serious, and not more of a skit than some things in the poem itself.'

Much of Eliot's poker-faced humour – like much of the savagery or violence in his work – derives from his confounding of the difference between 'a lark' and the 'serious', and the mock scholarly aspect of the notes is to the fore in annotations such as the one with which he glosses the lines 'To where Saint Mary Woolnoth kept the hours/With a dead sound on the final stroke of nine': 'A phenomenon which I have often noticed.' At times he seems almost to be taunting the philistine English poetry-lover who can't see beyond the Georgians, as when he recommends to those unable to read Sanskrit Paul Deussen's 1897 translation into German of Brihadaranyaka-Upanishad, where the 'fable of the meaning of the Thunder' can be found. His note, on the other hand, on Tiresias (the blind ancient Greek prophet who had been both man and woman) suggested a way of reading The Waste Land that has had a deep and lasting influence on the poem's reception, for it implied a coherent overall plan and a way of understanding the various characters the poem presents:

Tiresias, although a mere spectator and not indeed a 'character', is yet the most important personage in the poem, uniting all the rest. Just as the one-eyed merchant, seller of currants, melts into the Phoenician Sailor, and the latter is not wholly distinct from Ferdinand Prince of Naples, so all the women are one woman, and the two sexes meet in Tiresias. What Tiresias sees, in fact, is the substance of the poem.

This seems to encourage us to view The Waste Land not as a 'heap of broken images' or a series of sprawling, disconnected 'fragments' shored against the poet's ruins, but as a skilfully orchestrated jeremiad by a prophet-like creator who, rather than a pulpit, uses collage and allusion and other avant-garde (as well as traditional) poetic techniques to alert his followers to their perilous spiritual state. The note acts as both a declaration of the 'impersonality' of the poem and as a kind of prophylactic insulating Eliot from Tiresias. We are not, it warns, to assume that the poet is dramatising his own divided state and dilemmas through his all-uniting 'personage', although, reading against the grain, the note may also prompt us to think that this is exactly the use he is making of the old man with wrinkled dugs who foresees and foresuffers all.

The impressive range of references in Eliot's notes increased the sense among his initial readers that the poem was the expression of a mind bringing to bear a formidable intelligence and an exemplary understanding of culture on the chaotic, postwar world of 1922. 'The collocation of these two representatives of eastern and western asceticism, as the culmination of this part of the poem, is not an accident,' he writes of his twinning of Augustine's Confessions and the Buddha's Fire Sermon at the end of Part III. The introduction to 'What the Thunder Said' invites us to appreciate his deployment of themes widely separated in time and place: 'the journey to Emmaus, the approach to the Chapel Perilous (see Miss Weston's book) and the present decay of Eastern Europe' (in the drafts Eliot's 'hooded hordes' swarm over 'Polish plains' rather than 'endless plains').

But to what extent was the openness of the poem to its source texts a sign of Eliot's professional mastery of his medium, of his easy familiarity with literary greats such as Virgil and Dante and Spenser and Shakespeare, and to what extent was it the openness of a cross-gendered hysteric, one with nerves as bad as those of the unnamed woman in 'A Game of Chess' who implores her husband to stay with her? Ricks and McCue's exhaustive notes make conspicuous the dual nature of the relationship between Eliot's reading and his writing, the sense that his work often communicates of a poet who is at once making thoughtful, purposeful use of earlier texts, and at the same time desperately seeking solace or precedent in the words of others – grasping for something to help him escape the prison in whose lock he has heard the key turn once, and once only:

'Speak to me. Why do you never speak. Speak.
'What are you thinking of? What thinking? What?
'I never know what you are thinking. Think.'

'WONDERFUL,' Vivien wrote in the margin of this passage on the manuscript of The Waste Land. Ricks and McCue alert us to Joseph Conrad's The End of the Tether ('Why don't you speak? … What does it mean? … What's going on in that head of yours? What are you plotting against me there so hard that you can't say a word?'); a poem in Aldous Huxley's collection Leda ('Heart-rending question of women – never answered:/"Tell me, tell me, what are you thinking of?"'); and Conrad Aiken's The Jig of Forslin ('What are you thinking?') – as well as to a variant line of Eliot's own 'Skimbleshanks: The Railway Cat' ('he sees knows what you are thinking'). The connection between the narrator's emotional paralysis and the state of shellshocked soldiers returning from the First World War is implicit in the unspoken response that follows the woman's obsessive demands and questions: 'I think we are in rats' alley' – a trench in the Somme sector of the Western Front – 'Where the dead men lost their bones.'

Should we consider the 'personage' uniting and seeing the poem as a dispassionate, authoritative seer, or as a helplessly traumatised visionary? The answer is of course both; the point of the question is to suggest the contradictory extremes charted by Eliot's poetry, and necessary to it: central to his imagination was the compulsion to pit his yearning for discipline and control against a longing to renounce the will and yield to unknowable, inexplicable forces – 'The awful daring of a moment's surrender'. His use of allusions is particularly interesting in this respect, for while his notes detailing his sources allowed him to figure himself as a scholarly sage instructing his disciples in the canon of great texts, the borrowings themselves – or should we call them thefts? – can be read as enacting an opposite state of affairs, as dramatising a mind overrun and defenceless:

Poi s'ascose nel foco che gli affina
Quando fiam uti chelidon – O swallow swallow
Le Prince d'Aquitaine à la tour abolie

The choice of allusions here is often happily justified by people who have engaged with the poem in an academic context. What such justifications tend to overlook is the primary impression that the lines convey – that Eliot is speaking in tongues.

In one of his own accounts of the relationship between a poet's reading and writing, in the conclusion to The Use of Poetry and the Use of Criticism (his 1932-33 Norton Lectures), Eliot discusses the mysterious processes which give certain phrases or images what he calls 'personal saturation value'; by this he means that they come to represent or incarnate 'depths of feeling into which we cannot peer'. The model of intertextuality that he outlines in this conclusion characteristically involves death by water – a submarine descent followed by a wondrous sea-change and a miraculous resurrection. The imagery of 'Kubla Khan', for instance, had its origins in Coleridge's reading; that imagery 'sank to the depths of Coleridge's feeling, was saturated, transformed there – "those are pearls that were his eyes" – and brought up into daylight again'. Coleridge, alas, or so Eliot argues, made poor use of the passage in Purchas his Pilgrimage that his opium-addled subconscious reconfigured, because he lacked 'organisation'. Shakespeare, on the other hand, was able to find a 'rational use and justification' for the endless stream of saturated fragments rising from the ocean floor of his mind to its surface: 'again and again the right imagery, saturated while it lay in the depths of Shakespeare's memory, will rise like Anadyomene from the sea.'

The maritime opening of 'Marina' offers one of Eliot's most explicit and moving renditions of the theme of loss and recovery so important to his sense of the imagination's economy. Eliot considered the scene in which Pericles discovers that his daughter Marina (who was born at sea and has been long thought dead by her father) is in fact alive, to be the finest of the 'recognition scenes' in late Shakespeare:

What seas what shores what grey rocks and what islands
What water lapping the bow
And scent of pine and the woodthrush singing through the fog
What images return
O my daughter.

Ricks and McCue's multiple verbal analogues are perhaps best approached as an attempt to aggregate all the candidates from Eliot's reading that might have sunk, saturated with whatever meanings and emotions, into the poet's subconscious; and which then, whether impelled upwards by suffering and horror as in The Waste Land, or released, as in 'Marina', by the operations of grace, return as images, unbidden and beyond all customary perspectives – 'more distant than stars and nearer than the eye'. It is interesting that in The Use of Poetry and the Use of Criticism Eliot describes inspiration as 'negative', as the momentary overcoming of inhibitions, as an unexpected breaching of the self's defences:

To me it seems that at these moments, which are characterised by the sudden lifting of the burden of anxiety and fear which presses upon our daily life so steadily that we are unaware of it, what happens is something negative: that is to say, not 'inspiration' as we commonly think of it, but the breaking down of strong habitual barriers – which tend to re-form very quickly. Some obstruction is momentarily whisked away. The accompanying feeling is less like what we know as positive pleasure, than like a sudden relief from an intolerable burden.

'Marina' again exquisitely captures this dream of 'a world of time beyond me':

                         let me
Resign my life for this life, my speech for that unspoken,
The awakened, lips parted, the hope, the new ships.

This poem's faintly sketched titular character is one of a number of dreamlike female figures, part-saint, part-muse, who populate Eliot's poetry of the late 1920s and 1930s, and promise a momentary lifting of the burden of anxiety and fear; but not until he married, in 1957, his secretary at Faber & Faber, Valerie Fletcher, who was 38 years his junior, did these burdens truly lift, and Eliot awaken to the earthly joys so vividly renounced, or moved beyond, in poems such as 'Marina':

Those who sit in the sty of contentment, meaning
Death
Those who suffer the ecstasy of the animals, meaning
Death

Are become unsubstantial.

Eliot's final edition of his poetry (Collected Poems 1909-62) concludes with 'A Dedication to My Wife', in which the doting husband publicly commemorated the happiness of his second marriage with an explicitness that surprised many ('The breathing in unison//Of lovers whose bodies smell of each other'). I once heard that F.R. Leavis so disliked this poem that he stapled up the last page of his copy of the book so as not to have to read it. This tribute, it turns out, was one of a number of poems that Eliot composed celebrating his union with the woman whom he addresses as 'the tall girl' in erotic verses such as 'How the Tall Girl and I Play Together' and 'How the Tall Girl's Breasts Are'. I doubt that these would have appealed much to Leavis either, but they do offer graphic additional proof in support of Peter Ackroyd's assertion in his 1984 biography of Eliot that 'when he allowed his sexuality free access, when he was not struggling with his own demons, it was of a heterosexual kind':

When my tall girl sits astraddle on my lap,
She with nothing on and I with nothing on
And our middle parts are about their business,
I can stroke her back and her long white legs
And both of us are happy. Because she is a tall girl.

Eliot copied these verses out by hand in a notebook entitled Valerie's Own Book; and while it's good to know that, after the prolonged misery of his life with Vivien, he found bliss with the adored and adoring Valerie, it's also hard not to feel that such 'private words', to quote from the last line of 'A Dedication to My Wife', should have remained so.

In the preface that Ezra Pound composed for Valerie Eliot's edition of the original manuscript of The Waste Land, Pound declared, in justification of the project, that 'the more we know of Eliot, the better.' Possibly aficionados of any given writer will feel something like this about their chosen one, but it seems to me that there is something distinctive and extreme about the curiosity aroused by Eliot in both his contemporaries and in those who have pursued an interest in his work in the half-century following his death. One of the reasons that the 'Tall Girl' poems are so dispiriting is because, in their banality, they threaten to disperse the aura of mystery that has enveloped Eliot more or less since the publication of 'Prufrock'. As his fame spread, anecdotes and legends about Eliot's private life flourished on both sides of the Atlantic. They were propagated in particular by younger poets who had fallen under his spell, and felt driven to seek out biographical sources for the power and originality of the poetry they found so mesmerising: W.H. Auden believed that Eliot had had a mystical vision when he was a young child, Hart Crane was convinced that he was secretly gay, while Delmore Schwartz was a fount of scurrilous stories about Eliot's sex life, which, according to Schwartz, included a relationship with the Jewish woman referred to as Rachel née Rabinovitch in 'Sweeney among the Nightingales', who had jilted him and so made him anti-Semitic.

This mystique was principally the result of the compelling amalgam of the reticent and the confessional in his poetry, which often seems to encrypt some private guilt or nameless crime, but in a manner that renders inextricable the 'lark', to use Bennett's terms, from the 'serious': 'That corpse you planted last year in your garden,/Has it begun to sprout? Will it bloom this year?/Or has the sudden frost disturbed its bed?'; 'And you wait for a knock and the turning of a lock for you know the hangman's waiting for you/And perhaps you're alive/And perhaps you're dead/Hoo ha ha/Hoo ha ha/Hoo.' The tight grip that Valerie (who died in 2012) kept on the Eliot archive in the decades between his death and hers heightened curiosity about the material that it was assumed she was protecting from prying eyes. It is only recently, therefore, that the Eliot industry has been able to set about slaking this interest, but it has done so on all fronts and with impressive thoroughness: over the last five years six doorstopping volumes of the letters have been published, taking us up to 1933; four volumes (of a projected eight) of a digital edition of Eliot's complete prose have been released; the first volume of a two-volume biography by Robert Crawford has appeared, greatly increasing our knowledge of Eliot's life up until the publication of The Waste Land; and to these is now added this utterly authoritative edition of the text of the poems, which restores a missing line to 'The Hollow Men', prints a range of previously unpublished poems (from off-cuts of Old Possum's Book of Practical Cats to the late erotic verses), presents an editorial composite of material relating to The Waste Land, assembles all of Eliot's 'Improper Rhymes' (mainly consisting of the obscene and racist King Bolo poems Eliot so enjoyed composing and circulating among his male cronies), and even finds room for Eliot's translation of St-John Perse's Anabase. The apparatus includes, as well as the commentary, details of drafts and of textual variants, the publication history of individual poems and of each Eliot collection, a comprehensive bibliography, a wonderfully useful set of indexes, accounts of recordings made by Eliot, of stage and radio adaptations made by others – oh, in short, the lot! It is a phenomenal achievement; and although reading it cover to cover can feel like being stuck in some brilliantly devious Borges story, it surely sets standards that few succeeding editors of the complete works of poets of the last century are likely to attempt or to attain. Its only near rival in the ratio of text to editorial matter is The Complete Poems of Philip Larkin edited by Archie Burnett, a director, like Ricks, of Boston University's Editorial Institute (currently, alas, under threat of closure), which bulked out Larkin's four slim volumes to a staggering 729 pages.

While not all of the verbal analogues that the book's copious notes offer seem to me valuable or convincing, the extracts given from Eliot's letters and criticism are nearly always illuminating and worth reading. Some of these will be new even to Eliot experts, for the editors draw on correspondence that hasn't yet been published, as well as on a range of recondite sources and on various archival materials known only to select Eliot scholars. The effect is of a vast collage in which well-known quotes, such as Eliot's description of The Waste Land as 'just a piece of rhythmical grumbling', jostle with extracts that one vaguely remembers and passages that are completely fresh. Some of the extracts from letters that will appear in later volumes of Eliot's correspondence are particularly memorable. On New Year's Day of 1936, for instance, he wrote to his brother Henry with an account of his state of mind while writing The Waste Land that vividly captures the disastrous aspects of his marriage to Vivien:

I was of course too much engrossed in the horrors of my private life to notice much outside; and I was suffering from (1) a feeling of guilt in having married a woman I detested, and consequently a feeling that I must put up with anything (2) perpetually being told, in the most plausible way, that I was a clodhopper and a dunce. Gradually, through making friends, I came to find that English people of the sort that I found congenial were prepared to take me quite as an ordinary human being, and that I had merely married into a rather common suburban family with a streak of abnormality which in the case of my wife had reached the point of liking to give people pain. I shall always be grateful to a few people like the Woolfs who unconsciously helped me to regain my balance and self-respect.

This was written four years after he'd decided that he could cope no more with Vivien's unrelenting demands, which are figured here as positively sadistic, making his break for freedom by accepting an invitation to give the Norton Lectures at Harvard, and then, on his return from America, lodging with a priest in Kensington rather than returning to his increasingly distraught and desperate wife. They never divorced, but Eliot managed pretty much to avoid all contact with her until she was committed, in 1938, to an insane asylum near Finsbury Park. The following year he bleakly declared in a letter to John Hayward, with whom he would share a flat after the Second World War:

I have no family, no career, and nothing particular to look forward to in this world. I doubt the permanent value of everything I have written; I never lay with a woman I liked, loved or ever felt any strong physical attraction to; I no longer even regret this lack of experience; I no longer even feel acutely the desire for progeny which was very acute once.

Cited in the notes to 'Marina' as part of a discussion of Eliot's attitudes to parenthood, the passage suggests how deeply the role of the ascetic who had 'divested' himself 'of the love of created beings', to adapt the epigraph from the Spanish mystic St John of the Cross used for Sweeney Agonistes, appealed to Eliot as the only means of dissolving his feelings of shame and guilt. That a man capable of such a self-portrait should have ended up composing the 'Tall Girl' poems registers as a glorious upending of his quest to lead a saintly, almost posthumous existence. 'Because I do not hope to turn again,' opened 'Ash-Wednesday', Eliot's most penitent and penitential sequence, indicating his commitment to a life of self-denial; in the event his marriage to Valerie would instigate a 'sea-change' as miraculous and unpredictable as any in the late Shakespeare plays that meant so much to him.

In the 1930s, however, Eliot was concerned not with his chances of achieving personal let alone sexual happiness, which, as the letter to Hayward indicates, he rated pretty low, but with the narrative of personal salvation that he formally initiated by joining the Anglican Church in June 1927. It was as a Christian that Eliot interpreted the crises leading up to the outbreak of the war. In the stirring last paragraph of 'Thoughts after Lambeth' (Eliot's response to the resolutions passed by Anglican bishops at the Lambeth Conference of 1930), he figures himself and his fellow Christians as the last surviving hopes of Western Civilisation. Yet also implicit in his rhetoric of the embattled few is the notion that the looming political turmoil may offer a militant Christian church the opportunity to present itself as the only solution to the world's ills. Particularly striking, and unpalatable to the non-Christian reader, is Eliot's conviction that secular society is doomed:

The World is trying the experiment of attempting to form a civilised but non-Christian mentality. The experiment will fail; but we must be very patient in awaiting its collapse; meanwhile redeeming the time: so that the Faith may be preserved alive through the dark ages before us; to renew and rebuild civilisation, and save the World from suicide.

Ezra Pound, who saw sound economics – or at least his own distinctive brand of sound economics – as the obvious answer to Europe and America's social and political troubles, was particularly baffled by Eliot's turn to religion. 'This beats me, beats me,' was all he could answer when, in the course of a visit to il miglior fabbro in Italy, Eliot confided his anxiety about the fate of his soul after death.

Pound, inevitably, is the writer who features most often in this edition's assemblage of contexts for Eliot's poetry – nudging, cajoling, haranguing, harrumphing, decisively wielding his blue pencil or scribbling 'echt' against the good bits in the margins of The Waste Land. Dante, Shakespeare, Jules Laforgue and Tennyson also rack up substantial entries in the index. Those, however, schooled in the pantheon of great writers championed in Eliot's criticism, and familiar with his capacious salon des refusés, may be surprised to find lines and phrases by Emerson and Whitman cropping up so often as potential influences, for Eliot's few public comments on their work were at best lukewarm, at worst dismissive. 'Let there be commerce between us,' Pound declared, like some trade negotiator, in 'A Pact', a poem of 1913 in which he hails Whitman as his 'pig-headed father'. The many links discerned by Ricks and McCue between lines by the hyper-educated Eliot and his rude self-taught forebear suggest that a current of paternity ran between Whitman and Eliot too, but one that the fastidious, Dante-quoting, Anglicised exile wasn't keen to acknowledge.

The nature and extent of Pound's editing of the poem that started out in life as 'He Do the Police in Different Voices' (a quote from Our Mutual Friend) only became apparent when Valerie's facsimile edition of the drafts of The Waste Land was published in 1971. The 54 leaves of the manuscript of Eliot's most famous poem, which he had given to the American lawyer and patron of the arts John Quinn late in 1922, came to light in 1968, three years after Eliot's death. While at work on her edition, Valerie consulted Pound in the hope that he might be able to recall details of his discussions with Eliot about cuts and changes. Alas, now in his eighties, Pound could remember nothing, even when, in June 1969, she and Pound visited the New York Public Library together, and he held again the drafts of the poem that so influenced the history of 20th-century poetry: no flood of memories prompted him to speak. 'But,' Valerie later recalled, 'he was so moved by seeing it that he just sat for a long time in front of it, tears in his eyes.'


Evernote helps you remember everything and get organized effortlessly. Download Evernote.

王子今:“史识”与计算机“利器”

王子今:"史识"与计算机"利器"

当今计算机技术的进步和普及,显著冲击着社会文化的各个层次、各个角落。可以说,信息革命已经影响了社会上每一个人的生活情境和生活方式,而社会文化的诸多表现形式,也因此发生了变化。史学领域多数学人也普遍应用计算机技术检索史料、收集信息、整理思路、撰写论著。可以说,今天的史学,在学习方式和研究方式上都已进入以往学者难以想象的新境。清醒的历史学研究者面对这一情形,自然会思考史学方式的革新与史学传统的继承这两者之间的合理关系。



一 "汉宋两司马"面对的学术条件的进步
其实,史家面对学术条件的重要更新,在史学史的进程中可以看到前迹。
司马迁和司马光是中国古代史学史上具有时代高峰意义的大家,有人称之为"汉宋两司马"。他们的史学实践都曾经面对史学工作条件的重要进步。
在司马迁撰作《太史公书》即后来通称《史记》这部史学经典的时代,纸这种书写材料的最初出现,已经成为发明史上辉煌的一页。台湾中研院邢义田院士曾经以实验方式,测定了汉代竹木简的体积和重量,进而讨论简册的书写姿态、编联方式、保存制度等等,提出了不少新的认识。他考察司马迁《史记》以简牍为书写材料形成的篇幅,判断以木简的重量计,"达43.7~48.1公斤,甚至55.9公斤。如以新鲜的竹简计,则达58.33公斤;用新鲜红柳则更重达101.62公斤"!"以13855枚简抄成的《史记》,其体积约达一百八十倍,即284310立方公分左右。""汉代一部竹木简抄写的《史记》本文,体积上约为现代含三家注本《史记》约九十六倍!""如果仅计白文,汉代竹木简本的《史记》体积是现代纸本的二百二十五倍!""也就是说,现在在书架上放一部不含注解的《史记》白文,在汉代就须要最少二百二十五倍的空间。"(《汉代简牍的体积、重量和使用———以中研院史语所藏居延汉简为例》,《地不爱宝:汉代的简牍》,中华书局2011年版)甘肃天水出土年代为文景时期的放马滩纸,纸面平整光滑,有用细墨线描绘的山川道路图形。考古发现年代稍晚但仍相当于西汉中期的古纸,还有灞桥纸等。有人说,敦煌悬泉置遗址还发现了汉武帝时代的纸文书(《中国考古学·秦汉卷》,中国社会科学出版社2010年版,第742页)。司马迁时代纸虽然尚未全面普及,但以他在朝廷文化中枢部门工作的身份,不会接触不到这种民间墓葬和普通遗址曾经出土的普通人已经使用的书写材料。没有迹象表明他撰写《史记》已经改变了不免辛劳的旧式简牍书写方式,但是也不能绝对否定他曾经使用过纸。不过,司马迁对于史学的重要推进,《史记》史学经典地位的形成,似乎并未借助纸的使用。
司马光编纂《资治通鉴》的时代,则面临中国文化史上的又一次革命,即印刷术的进步。司马光生于1019年,毕昇时已49岁。《资治通鉴》成书时,活字印刷术应当已经问世。然而至今未闻印刷术的进步对于司马光的创造性的工作提供了怎样的便利。

也就是说,《史记》和《资治通鉴》史学成就的伟大,似乎并没有表现出与学术条件的技术性进步有直接的关系。



二 史学的手段进步与史学的学术进步
回顾史学进步的各个关键点,技术层面的进步,似乎都并没有形成显著的决定性的推进力。也许计算机技术与此前的学术手段的进步有很多不同,但是要断言这种技术提升会在很大程度上改变史学的学术走向或说形成革命性的积极影响,除了开发想象力之外,还需要实践的证明。
过去史学学者做学问,爬梳史料的功夫,主要是靠卡片的制作。据说陈登原教授曾经教导学生,每天抄若干卡片,积功数十年,自然可以成就大学问。有人说,陈直教授去世时,留下40多个大信封,应当都是有所思考,准备进行研究的课题。其中盛装的,大概都是与研究主题相关的卡片一类史料摘抄。这种已设定主题之下的资料搜集,现在可以利用计算机技术替代,节省我们的时间,减轻我们的辛劳了。
利用计算机查找相关资料,现在已经是大家通常的工作方式。记得我第一次尝试采用这种方式写作,是完成拙著《中国盗墓史》时。承陈爽博士热心帮助,为我检索"二十四史"中关"陵""墓""冢""坟"的资料。说来至今心存感激,我使用的第一台电脑,就是陈爽帮我"攒"的。他帮我检索有关盗墓的资料,是借助台湾中研院的"瀚典"。当然这一检索系统也是以中华书局标点本"二十四史"为文献基础的。陈爽的帮助当然提高了写作效率和研究质量,但是后来回想,注意到当时采用的这种工作方式仍然有明显的不足:1.当时尚不具备检索"四库全书"等较大规模文献集成的条件,未能得到"二十四史"以外诸多文献的更为充备的相关信息。2.以"陵""墓""冢""坟"为线索得到的资料,远非盗墓史相关信息的全部,如《三国志》卷六《魏书·袁绍传》裴松之注引《魏氏春秋》载绍《檄州郡文》曰:"……又梁孝王,先帝母弟,坟陵尊显,松柏桑梓,犹宜恭肃,而(曹)操率将校吏士亲临发掘,破棺裸尸,略取金宝,至令圣朝流涕,士民伤怀。又署发丘中郎将、摸金校尉,所过堕突,无骸不露。"所谓"署发丘中郎将、摸金校尉"这一盗墓史的典型情节可以因"坟""陵"的检索得知。然而《宋书·前废帝纪》"以魏武帝有发邱中郎将、摸金校尉,乃置此二官,以建安王休佑领之"与《南史·宋本纪中·前废帝》"以魏武有发丘中郎将、摸金校尉,乃置此二官,以建安王休仁、山阳王休佑领之"的记载,则不能通过"陵""墓""冢""坟"诸字的检索得知。相关类似情形,一定还有一些。
便利史料获得的程序以提高研究效率,自然为历史学学者深心向往。就此而言,古来类书的编纂,提供了一些方便。洪业先生经营的"引得"的编制,是尤其重要的贡献。但是大家都知道,即使全文逐字检索实现,理解文献的历史文化内涵,依然是研究者第一位的工作。虽然检索手段越来越先进,但是检索的主题,必须由研究者凭借主观判断来选定。学术见识的水准,往往可以于此体现。如果选定范围过窄,遗漏了重要信息,不免遗憾。而选定检索目标过宽,形成海量的检索结果,也会使人无所措手足。
计算机技术在史学领域已经应用有年,现今已极少有史学学者不使用计算机。然而通过近期的史学观察可以得知,实现有显著推进性的突出学术进步的主要因素,似乎是先进思路的开拓和新出资料的公布,并不在于计算机技术作为研究手段的简单应用。
关于学术工具的意义,可以回顾这样一个故事。元代学者许有壬得到朋友赠送的以未央宫汉瓦制作的好砚,感激之余,又谦称"芜学",表示自己的才质拙劣,并不能使用此"利器"完成美好的作品:"惠然匣送感高义,但惜所与非所宜。公才真是谪仙裔,善事利器方相资。嗟予芜学忝词馆,虽有此器无能为。"(《李惟中学士自西台侍御召入以未央宫瓦砚为贶作此谢之》,《至正集》卷一一,文渊阁四库全书本)借用许有壬自谦之语,可以说史学研究如果只有可以称作"利器"的优异手段,而缺乏高明识见,则必然是"虽有此器无能为"的。

三 "器"与"史识"
史学的突出成就,除了沉静踏实的工作,甘心"坐冷板凳"的精神,面对青灯古卷的辛劳而外,也需要灵性,需要思辨能力,需要创新追求,在一定意义上,也需要艺术素养与美学理念。从这几个方面来说,计算机技术都是无法完全替代的。而后者的优异表现,人们常称之为"史识"。"史识"是"史才"修炼必然的追求和必备的条件。
刘知幾说:"夫史才之难,其难甚矣!"(《史通·核才》,刘知幾撰,浦起龙释:《史通通释》,上海古籍出版社1978年版)又说:"史才须有三长。""三长谓才也,学也,识也。夫有学而无才,亦犹有良田百顷,黄金满籝,而使愚者营生,终不能致于货殖者矣。如有才而无学,亦犹思兼匠石,巧若公输,而家无楩柟斧斤,终不果成其宫室者矣。犹须好是正直,善恶必书,使骄主贼臣所以知惧,此则为虎傅翼,善无可加,所向无敌者矣。"(《史通·原序》)对于历史论著的品级,明代学者章潢以为合理的评判条件也是"史识、史才、史学三者"(《图书编》卷一〇,文渊阁四库全书本)。
"子曰:'工欲善其事,必先利其器。'"(《论语·卫灵公》,金良年:《论语译注》,上海古籍出版社2004年版,第186页)"善""事"的向往,往往导致"利""器"的追求。计算机技术,就是今天学术的"利器"。不过,如果只凭借工具的优化和技术的提升,而缺乏"才""学""识"的修养和锤炼,则好比"有良田百顷,黄金满籝","犹思兼匠石,巧若公输",仍难以获得真正的成功,"终不能致于货殖","终不果成其宫室",距离"为虎傅翼,善无可加,所向无敌"的境界,当然更为遥远。

《西游记》中孙悟空手中"重一万三千五百斤"的"如意金箍棒"就是这种寄托了古人对奇效工具之向往的神异"利器"。孙悟空最初见到,就"心中暗喜道:'想必这宝贝如人意!'"果然这"海藏中"的"神珍铁"可以"变做个绣花针儿,藏在耳内",也可以随意而"长",甚至"上抵三十三天,下至十八层地狱"。不过,这"宝贝"的变化,却要"如"猴王之"意",要凭借孙悟空的"神通"。按孙悟空自己的话说:"物各有主。这宝贝镇于海藏中,也不知几千百年,可可的今岁放光。龙王只认做是块黑铁,又唤作天河镇底神珍。那厮每都抬扛不动,请我亲去拿之。那时此宝有二丈多长,斗来粗细,被我挝他一把,意思嫌大,他就小了许多;再教小些,他就又小了许多;再教小些,他就又小了许多"(《西游记》第三回《四海千山皆拱伏,九幽十类尽除名》,明书林杨闽斋刊本)。将这一讲"物"和"主"关系的神话故事看作可以对认识学术工具与学术家的关系有所启示的寓言,也许是适宜的。


显而易见,计算机技术的应用毕竟为我们的史学研究提供了便利,提高了效率。开掘相关方法以更好地服务史学学术的进步,无疑是应当鼓励的。
可以说,我们今天还难以预想电子技术和信息科学未来的进步。也许这种进步会突破许多成见,开拓超出我们现今想象的新的学术空间和学术路径。那么,我们也只能面对当时的情形决定当时的工作方式。陈寅恪先生曾经以拟首联"孙行者"求对的方式作为试题,据说有应答"胡适之"者。就我们完全无法准确预想的计算机技术进步而言,大概且"行"且"适之",是比较合理的态度。
(本文首载于《史学月刊》2015年01期)
Evernote helps you remember everything and get organized effortlessly. Download Evernote.

The Truth Is in the Detail

  The Truth Is in the Detail On Paul Celan’s writing between languages. By Lucy Ives Originally Published: 八月 17, 2026 Share Photo: Gisèle C...